Next Generation Partners

Insurance: Dispute resolution in Canada

Blake, Cassels & Graydon LLP

Blake, Cassels & Graydon LLP's insurance litigation practice is spearhead by disputes specialist David Tupper from Calgary. The firm handles complex insurance cases for global and multinational companies who rely on insurance coverage. The firm has deep expertise assisting clients with insurance claims, class actions, arbitrations and issues related to constitutional law. The practice is often handling novel issues for the insurance sector, such as a coverage dispute involving time detection clauses in pollution policies. Tupper is an insurance litigation heavyweight acting on a wide range of matters from subrogation actions, coverage actions to liability defence mandates. He also has experience assisting clients with property and liability policies and reinsurance losses. In Montréal, Matthew Liben is well-versed in insurance coverage disputes, advising insurance companies, policyholders and insurance syndicates. He is the go-to for cyber insurance cases.

Praxisleiter:

David Tupper


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Matthew Liben


Kernmandanten

Chubb


Emani Mutual Insurance


Intact


Lloyd’s Underwriters and Lloyd’s Canada


Ovivo


Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Company of Canada


Royal Bank of Canada


Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company


Borden Ladner Gervais LLP

Borden Ladner Gervais LLP fields a sizeable insurance practice with dedicated litigation experts to advise domestic and foreign insurers on nationwide claims and coverage mandates. The firm handles the full gamut of claims, from class actions to subrogation, acting as defence counsel for clients in a wide range of sectors including automotive, rail and road, maritime, aviation. It also is well-versed in liability claims related to products, occupiers, directors, officers and professionals. Clientele reach out to the firm for its experience in litigation, mediation, arbitration and advocacy at all levels of Canadian courts. Rebecca Bush leads the disputes group and insurance and tort liability practice from Toronto. She specializes in public authority litigation and tort litigation as well as crisis management and incident response and defence. Gilbert Hourani sits in Montréal and defends insurers in insurance litigations related to professional liability of general and specialized contractors and engineering firms. Patrick Heinsen advises global insurance providers and health authorities on class actions and coverage issues.

Praxisleiter:

Rebecca Bush


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Gilbert Houranil; Marc-André McCann; Laura Day; Patrick Heinsen


Kernmandanten

Lloyd’s of London


The City of Toronto


Chubb / Ace


Travelers


Hospital Insurance Reciprocal of Canada


Desjardins Group


Encon


The Cooperators


Sun Life


Trisura


Definity


Economical Insurance


Ecclesiastical


Metrolinx


Intact Insurance


Zurich Insurance Company/ Zurich Canadian


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advised Lloyd’s Underwriters on the case Workman Optometry Professional Corporation v. Certas Home and Auto Insurance Company.
  • Represented Underwriters at Lloyd’s of London in defending a C$217m claim by Canadian Natural Resources.
  • Advised A49 Architects on the Assiniboine Park Conservatory litigation in Manitoba respecting the design and construction of the APC Conservatory.

McCarthy Tétrault

McCarthy Tétrault is a premier insurance litigation practice which advises on insurance mandates across North America. The firm defends the rights of directors and officers in D&O litigation against insurers related to denial or cancellation of coverage, and acts on insurance litigation claims and crisis management for domestic insurance clients. The team is led out of Toronto by Christopher Hubbard, who is an expert in commercial disputes, class actions, professional negligence and insurance coverage litigation. He is often sought out by Canadian corporate executives for his expertise in handling claims. Christine Lonsdale works alongside Hubbard in Toronto and advises financial institutions and insurance clients on mitigating risks.

Praxisleiter:

Christopher Hubbard


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Christine Lonsdale


Kernmandanten

Navacord


Programmed Insurance Brokers


Canadian Maritime Engineering


770 dentists and dental corporations


Danone


TD Insurance Meloche Monnex


Desjardins Financial Services Firm


Desjardins Global Asset Management


The Personal Insurance Company


Farm Mutual Reinsurance Plan


Canadian Association of Mutual Insurance Companies


and Ontario Mutual Insurance Association


RBC Life Insurance Company


Highlight-Mandate


Lenczner Slaght

Lenczner Slaght centres its Toronto-based insurance practice on representing clients in policy, coverage and defence mandates. The firm’s bench has strong expertise in insurance matters and before all levels of courts. The team has litigated cases among and against insurers involving a wide array of issues, such as trigger of coverage, covered and excluded claims, obligations, allocation of defence and indemnity. The firm is noted for its work in the reinsurance space, where it advises insurance carriers on policy interpretation, bad faith and punitive damages. Outside of this, it also handles class actions, director’s and officer’s liability, environmental property damage claims and professional negligence claims. Practice head Nina Bombier is an insurance expert who handles complex insurance cases involving coverage issues, product liability claims and environmental contamination cases. Mark Veneziano is experienced in insurance and commercial litigation, while Aoife Quinn is a civil litigation specialist.

Praxisleiter:

Nina Bombier


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Mark Veneziano; Aoife Quinn


Kernmandanten

Topper Linen Supply


EllisDon


Insurance Bureau of Canada


Law Society of Ontario


CFT Clear Finance Technology


Boland Romaine


AIG Insurance Company of Canada


Menkes Developments Inc. and Bay Yorkville Developments


Highlight-Mandate


  • Represented XL Specialty Insurance Company as primary post-filing insurer to the debtor and its directors and officers in CCAA proceeding.
  • Represented Stewart Title in a claim advanced under the Stewart Title residential gold policy for construction deficiencies in a home.

Stikeman Elliott LLP

Stikeman Elliott LLP handles insurance litigation and coverage advice for domestic and international clients. The firm is noted for its prowess in handling class action defence involving insurance issues. The team is also experienced in handling disputes claims and coverage litigation, director’s and officer’s liability, environmental claims and professional negligence issues. It also leverages the firm’s expertise in corporate and M&A to advise on claims and disputes arising from corporate transactions. Alan D’Silva co-leads the insurance disputes practice and is known for his focus on class actions, corporate and commercial disputes. He leads the team from Toronto, while Éric Azran leads from Montréal and handles civil and commercial litigation, while Michael Mestinsek spearheads the Calgary advocacy group handling litigation, arbitration and alternative dispute resolution.

Praxisleiter:

Éric Azran; Alan D’Silva; Michael Mestinsek


Kernmandanten

Aviva Insurance Company of Canada


AXA XL


Veolia Water Technologies


Lloyd’s of London insurance syndicate


The Co-operators Group


Zurich Insurance Company


Allstate Insurance Company


Bondfield Construction Company


Travelers Insurance Company of Canada


Highlight-Mandate


Dentons

Dentons‘s national insurance sector group utilizes the firm’s global network to advise multinational insurance organizations on insurance issues domestically and globally. The firm advises clients on coverage disputes and commercial litigation involving insurance companies and insurance issues. Practice head Douglas Stewart leads the insurance disputes practice from Toronto and represents insurers and professionals in coverage matters involving director’s and officer’s liability, errors and omissions insurance and environmental policies. He is also adept at handling professional negligence claims and representing clients in commercial and contractual disputes.

Praxisleiter:

Douglas Stewart


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Deepshikha Dutt


Referenzen

‘They have a very well-resourced team in insurance so are able to respond to requests in a timely manner. Associates are excellent.’

‘The individuals I work with are very responsive and timely in providing feedback. A well-resourced and knowledgeable team.’

Kernmandanten

Carcillo ats. Canadian Hockey League


Enbridge Pipelines


Continental Casualty Company


ACE Property and Casualty Insurance Company


Chubb Insurance Company of Canada (Chubb)


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advised Carcillo ats. Canadian Hockey League on a class action related to allegations of abuse against hockey players committed from 1977-2020 in all of the Canadian Minor Junior hockey leagues.
  • Advised Enbridge Pipelines on a dispute related to the interpretation of crossing agreements entered into prior to construction and how those crossing agreements can be varied in the field.
  • Represented Continental Casualty Company in proposed class action proceedings before the Superior Court of Quebec on behalf of all individuals who have purchased a protection plan.

Torys

Torys is sought out for its knowledge handling insurance regulatory claims and disputes. The team is well positioned to advise clients in numerous sectors such as consumer services, healthcare, life sciences, tech and financial services. Linda Plumpton co-leads the Toronto-based team, alongside David Outerbridge. Plumpton has a wealth of expertise handling insurance litigation and representing clients in all levels of courts in Ontario, the Supreme Court of Canada and the Federal Court. Outerbridge is a class actions specialist who is noted for his speciality in regulatory insurance issues. He advises both insurers and brokers on insurance litigation.

Praxisleiter:

Linda Plumpton; David Outerbridge


Referenzen

‚I work with Linda Plumpton specifically because in my opinion she is one of the top advocates in Canada and she has developed a deep understanding of our business in Canada through working closely with us on a number of complex matters.‘

Kernmandanten

Vienna Insurance


Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association


Canadian Dental Service Programs


Highlight-Mandate


  • Represented Wiener Städtische Versicherung AG Vienna Insurance in a claim and subsequent appeal against Infrassure for breach of contract and breach of obligations under a retrocession agreement.
  • Represented CLHIA in a case as a proposed intervener before the Supreme Court of Canada in the matter of Thomson v ivari.
  • Advised CDSPI on a judicial review proceeding in the Alberta Court of King’s Bench, challenging decisions made by the Alberta dental regulator.