Leading Associates

Planning and environment in Ireland

A&L Goodbody LLP

A&L Goodbody LLP‘s planning and environment team provides integrated planning, environmental, and climate action advice to domestic and international corporates, state bodies, local authorities, and financial institutions. It assists clients across a wide range of sectors including energy, transport, utilities, and construction. Market leader Alison Fanagan SC co-heads the practice group and is an experienced commercial litigator, specialising in environment-related regulatory litigation and judicial reviews in particular. Fellow co-head Alan Roberts often advises clients on their interaction with environmental regulatory enforcement agencies, and on contaminated land clean up matters.

Praxisleiter:

Alan Roberts; Alison Fanagan


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Brendan Curran; Jason Milne


Referenzen

‘Knowledge and willingness to respond to questions.’

‘Alan Roberts and Brendan Curran – thorough and timely in their responses.’

‘The team is very responsive and can act quickly, regardless of how short the timeframe is.’

Kernmandanten

Abbott Nutritional


FuturEnergy Ireland


Statkraft Ireland Limited


Orsted Ireland


Land Development Agency


Avalonia Partnership


Coom Energy Limited


Planree Limited


Transport Infrastructure Ireland


Uisce Éireann


Codling Wind Park Limited


EP UK Investments Ltd


BOC Gases Ireland Limited


Airbnb Ireland Unlimited Company


Quintain Developments Ireland Limited


EDF Renewable Ireland Ltd


Parkwind N.V.


HPREF ICAV


Sazerac Company, Inc


Gas Networks Ireland


PJ Hegarty & Sons UC


Fingal County Council


Net Zero Energy Limited


Coillte


Barryroe Offshore Energy plc


ESB


Ballycumber Wind Farm Limited


Blackrock Investment Management (UK) Lim


Aldgate Developments Limited


Power Capital Renewable Energy Limited


Irish Distillers Limited


ProAmpac UK Ltd


Bremore Ireland Port Designated Activity Company


Glenveagh Homes Limited


Knockacummer Windfarm Limited


GE Vernova/ Arklow Energy Limited


Jazz Pharmaceuticals Inc.


DWS/Deutsche Asset Management Limited


Johnson Service Group plc


Spencer Place Development Company Ltd


Allied Irish Bank plc


Grange Backup Power Ltd


Enva Ireland Ltd


Goldman Sachs


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advising Transport Infrastructure Ireland on all public law, planning, environmental, railway safety, general health and safety and compulsory purchase matters associated with Dublin’s MetroLink project.
  • Advising Uisce Éireann on the Greater Dublin Drainage Project, which comprises a new 500,000 population equivalent waste water treatment plant, pumping station, 11.7km orbital sewer, 11km outfall tunnel, and associated pumping stations.
  • Advising Bremore Ireland Port relative to the development of a new deepwater port on the east coast of Ireland, including providing strategic advice on the necessary policy considerations that need to be in place in advance of an application for development consent being made.

Arthur Cox

The environment and planning team at Arthur Cox stands out for its work advising clients on major infrastructure projects across the country, as well as for its environmental advice on a significant number of strategic housing development projects, and its work defending judicial review challenges to environmental planning consents. Additionally, the firm is at the forefront of advising clients on circular economy matters. Notable individual Danielle Conaghan heads the team and has over 19 years’ experience advising on the full lifecycle of large-scale project delivery. Yvonne Scannell has particular expertise in the areas of water, waste, and resources law, and Jacinta Conway has focused her practice exclusively on environmental and related planning matters for the last nine years.

Praxisleiter:

Danielle Conaghan


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Jacinta Conway; Yvonne Scannell


Referenzen

‘The strength and depth of the team and their expertise in this area has been hugely beneficial to us compared to other firms that we have used.’

‘The quality and knowledge of the team is excellent.’

‘Responsive to queries at any time, with well-calibrated responses.’

Kernmandanten

Diageo


Corio Generation


Energia


National Broadband Ireland (NBI)


Cignal Infrastructure Ltd


Cairn Homes


Kilsaran International


Marlet Property Group


Strategic Power


Analog Devices Inc (ADI)


Uisce Éireann


Wind Energy Ireland


Malone O’Regan Consulting Engineers


Greensource


Merck Sharpe & Dohme (UK) Limited


Statkraft Ireland


Boliden Tara Mines DAC


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advising Corio Generation on all aspects of the development of the Sceirde Rocks 400MW offshore windfarm, one of Ireland’s first projects to be given special ‘relevant project’ status, and the only such project on the west coast of Ireland.
  • Advising Irish Cement Limited/CRH on the successful defence of two separate judicial review proceedings before the Court of Appeal on appeal from the Commercial Court against the Environmental Protection Agency’s decision to grant a revised licence to replace fossil fuel with non-fossil waste-based solid recovered fuel (SRF) at its cement factory in Limerick.
  • Advising National Broadband Ireland on all planning and environmental matters related to the roll out of the National Broadband Plan, the single largest state infrastructure concession ever to be tendered in Ireland.

Fieldfisher

Fieldfisher stands out for its expertise in advising planning and environmental regulatory bodies across the country, with deep knowledge of the legal framework within which key planning and environmental authorities, such as the EPA, ABP, OPR, IFI, and AFR operate. JP McDowell is an administrative and regulatory law specialist, acting in particular in the area of planning and development. Zoe Richardson also advises key clients including the EPA, ABP, and OPR on a range of complex advisory queries, including overseeing a caseload of almost 200 ongoing sets of judicial review proceedings. Another key contact is Jonathan Moore, who works closely with the EPA, whom he assists with their licensing and enforcement functions.

Praxisleiter:

JP McDowell; Zoe Richardson; Jonathan Moore


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Rory Ferguson


Referenzen

‘The responsiveness and availability of senior partners is exceptional, and nothing is a problem. The team has represented us on many complicated matters over the last number of years and we have found the advice and representation in court to be of the highest professional standard.’

‘The team have a unique practice profile of dealing with high level state-side regulatory matters. They carry out a practice which involves advisory work and high-level litigation (up to the CJEU) but importantly also involve their own solicitors in carrying out lower tier enforcement litigation which ensures deep, ingrained litigation skills that serve us when instructing them in the higher-tier litigation.’

‘One point of note is that Jonathan Moore is a former barrister which really makes a difference in terms of understanding the required approach to litigation and their team draws on expertise from various backgrounds. Rory Ferguson, for example, brings aviation regulatory experience (critical for aviation-related planning cases of which there have been many).’

Kernmandanten

An Bord Pleanála


Environmental Protection Agency


Office of Planning Regulator


Suntory Beverage & Food GB&I


Inland Fisheries Ireland


Agri-Food Regulator


Sigmaroc Plc


SSE Plc


Highlight-Mandate


  • Represented An Bord Pleanála in a preliminary reference to the Court of Justice of the European Union in relation to the interpretation of the Water Framework Directive 2000/60/EC.
  • Advised the EPA in respect of the defence of an appeal against a decision of the High Court to grant an injunction restraining a large commercial peat operator from extracting peat in the absence of a licence.
  • Advised ABP in respect of a leapfrog appeal to the Supreme Court brought by Crofton Buildings Management Company in respect of a decision of the High Court to remit a planning application to ABP.

Matheson LLP

The planning and environmental team at Matheson LLP is a part of the firm’s wider commercial litigation and dispute resolution team. It stands out for its experience of advising clients on the environmental aspects of large-scale developments, such as strategic infrastructure projects, and representing them in complex and precedent-setting planning matters and disputes. Market leader Nicola Dunleavy SC heads the practice, bringing over 25 years of expertise in environmental dispute resolution and regulatory enforcement. She is renowned for representing high-profile clients in complex environmental and planning matters, including judicial review challenges and the revision of planning applications. Another key individual is Ruadhán Kenny, who focuses on planning and environmental disputes and advisory work.

Praxisleiter:

Nicola Dunleavy SC


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Ruadhán Kenny


Referenzen

‘What makes Nicola Dunleavy and her team unique is their knowledge and expertise in the planning and environment sector.’

‘When working with Nicola Dunleavy and her team, you are always certain that they will keep you informed and updated on changing laws affecting the practice area. When you give instructions on a matter you receive a reply setting out both timelines and pricing, always followed by a call.’

‘This team is superb – they are really invested in the client’s business and work hard to understand how the business works and what they can do to assist the client to achieve their goals.’

Kernmandanten

MOWI Ireland


Ecopower Limited


Beacon Hospital


Highlight-Mandate


  • Representing Mowi Ireland in the defence of three judicial review challenges to the grant of an aquaculture licence.
  • Representing EcoPower in the defence of a judicial review challenge to the grant of planning permission which raises novel issues regarding the jurisdiction of the national planning body.
  • Advising Macquarie Asset Management on planning issues connected with its acquisition of the Beacon Hospital business.

McCann FitzGerald LLP

The environment and planning team at McCann FitzGerald LLP is recognised for its expertise advising clients on the environmental aspects of major public transport projects, as well as on novel renewable energy projects across the country. Notable individual Brendan Slattery has experience in both contentious and non-contentious matters, having advised a range of clients on the environmental aspects of energy security cases, such as assisting a major client on its application for substitute consent in respect of a number of onshore renewable energy projects. Other key contacts include Michelle Doyle, who specialises in the environmental risk management of major projects, and Sinéad Martyn, who has particular experience in assisting clients with the environmental issues arising from complex infrastructure projects, from project inception to post-consent judicial review challenges.

Praxisleiter:

Brendan Slattery; Michelle Doyle


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Sinéad Martyn


Referenzen

‘McCann’s planning team are great. If there is a planning issue I would not pass them by.’

‘Brendan Slattery and his team are experts in their field. They are up to date on all matters in the sector and willing to share this with you even if they are not involved in a transaction. They want to resolve matters and move things along.’

‘McCann FitzGerald have real expertise when dealing with planning and environmental issues. The knowledge regarding new requirements under the Local Government Act was excellent and helped us deal with councillors in a challenging situation.’

Kernmandanten

Transport Infrastructure Ireland


The National Transport Authority


Galway County Council


Limerick City and County Council


Fingal County Council


Land Development Agency


Bord na Móna


Bartra


Glenveagh


Statkraft


Aer Lingus


Ryanair


Lioncor


MaresConnect


Apollo Submarine Cable Limited (Vodafone/Meta)


Highlight-Mandate


  • Providing all planning and environmental support to the National Transport Authority on the biggest public transport project in the history of the state, BusConnects.
  • Supported Statkraft in its consenting strategy and planning submission to An Bord Pleanála in 2024, including the review of its EIAR and NIS, which accompanied this application.
  • Representing a host of clients in proceedings in the specialist Planning and Environment Court within the High Court, including Cairn, Greystar, Lioncor, Statkraft, Ryanair, Aer Lingus, Breedon Cement, Bartra, Tetrarch, and Sandymark.

Philip Lee LLP

Philip Lee LLP‘s environment and climate team has recently been increasingly focused on climate action, renewable energy, and biodiversity enhancement work. Alice Whittaker has an extensive background in litigation, and at present focuses her practice on advising project developers on complex environmental consent procedures. The renowned Rachel Minch SC is highly regarded for her expertise in handling judicial reviews of decisions related to the planning and licensing of environmentally significant development projects. Her work spans key sectors, including strategic transport initiatives and energy infrastructure, focusing on projects that have a substantial environmental impact. Leonora Mullett has broad experience of advising across a range of environmental matters, specifically relating to wildlife and water quality law. Another key individual is Maeve Delargy, who often acts for key clients in environmental transactional and regulatory work, and stands out for her expertise in significant judicial review proceedings.

Praxisleiter:

Alice Whittaker; Rachel Minch SC; Leonora Mullett


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Alison Hardiman


Referenzen

‘Very well informed and have a wealth of knowledge on planning and environmental matters.’

‘Alice Whittaker is well versed in E&P matters. Rachel Minch is such a pleasant person to have on your team – informed, knowledgeable and steady!’

‘Alice Whittaker and Alison Hardiman are two individuals I would particularly commend to anyone looking for legal advice and support. They have an encyclopedic knowledge of Irish planning and environmental law which is coupled with an exemplary dedication to their clients.’

Kernmandanten

An Bord Pleanála


Aqua Comms


RWE Renewables Ireland Limited


Premier Periclase Limited


Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland


ScottishPower Renewables / Iberdrola


Commissioner for Environmental Information


Emerging Markets Power (EM Power)


Department of the Environment, Climate and Communications


Marine Institute


Commissioners for Irish Lights


Aquaculture Licences Appeals Board


Coillte


Doyle Shipping Group


Heygaz


Corrib Oil


Port of Cork Company


Hines


Power Capital Renewable Energy


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advising RWE Renewables Ireland Limited on the development of the Dublin Array offshore wind project, one of the four ‘phase one’ projects that were successful in Ireland’s first offshore auction (ORESS 1).
  • Supporting the Department of the Environment, Climate and Communications (DECC) in the preparation of Ireland’s first Designated Maritime Area Plan (DMAP) for the South Coast of Ireland (SC-DMAP), identifying areas for future offshore wind projects.
  • Advising Premier Periclase Limited on a significant green transition project to transform an operational industrial facility located on a large brownfield site into a clean energy centre serving a new campus for industrial and commercial uses, requiring sustainable heat and power.

Beauchamps LLP

The planning and environmental department at Beauchamps LLP has over 20 years of experience advising on the full breadth of non-contentious environmental law and related planning and waste management matters. It also regularly advises clients on contentious issues such as judicial review proceedings. Team lead Stuart Conaty often assists renewable energy organisations and local authorities with all planning and environmental aspects associated with property and infrastructure projects. Other key members of the team include Ainsley Heffernan, who has extensive experience of advising clients on all environmental issues involved in complex infrastructure projects.

Praxisleiter:

Stuart Conaty


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Ainsley Heffernan


Referenzen

‘Highly experienced and professional team offering pragmatic advice to clients on energy and planning matters in a timely manner.’

‘Stuart Conaty is a pleasure to work with. He is responsive and a very good communicator and offers pragmatic advice and solutions on planning and energy matters.’

‘Excellent team. Experienced, client focused and knowledgeable.’

Kernmandanten

ABO Wind


ART Generation


Bord na Móna


Clúid


Codling Wind Park


Dublin City Council


EDF Renewables


FuturEnergy Ireland


Mercury Renewables


RES Group


Respond


RWE Renewables


Simply Blue Energy Kinsale


Terra Solar


Údarás na Gaeltachta


Western Power


Wind Energy Ireland


Source Galileo


The Platform ICAV


IDA Ireland


Lens Media


Irish Wind Farmers Association


Ormonde Organics


Source Galileo


Regnum Renewables


Shannon Energy Corporation


Maritime Area Regulatory Authority


Bowbeck DAC


Amhola


Axis Construction


BMor


Cloghroe Developments Limited


Ardarostig Developments Limited


AMC Properties Limited


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advising Lens Media Limited in relation to its proposed development of a state-of-the-art media park on a circa 23-hectare site in Grange Castle, County Dublin.
  • Advising EDF Renewables Ireland Limited in relation to two of its pipeline projects, the proposed circa 46 MW Seskin Wind Farm in County Carlow and the proposed circa 46MW Lackareagh Wind Farm in County Clare.
  • Engaged (in association with BVG Associates and Gavin and Doherty Geosolutions) by Wind Energy Ireland and Green Tech Skillnet to develop an online interactive resource to guide existing and potential offshore wind farm developers through the consenting and development process for offshore wind development in Ireland.

Eversheds Sutherland

Eversheds Sutherland‘s planning and environmental team advises clients across a range of contentious and non-contentious matters, including assisting a number of offshore wind and data centre developers with ongoing issues around electricity supply. Notably, team lead Stephen Barry is a seasoned litigator who regularly represents property developers, businesses, and public sector bodies in environment-related contentious matters, with a particularly strong track record in defending judicial review proceedings.

Praxisleiter:

Stephen Barry


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Neil O’Mahony


Referenzen

‘Stephen Barry provides excellent, well-thought-out, solution-driven advice in a practical and clear manner.’

‘This is a growing team and rapidly building its name in the area of planning and environmental law. They are one of the limited number of P&E specialists with experience in the energy sector. We have found their assistance on energy-related E&P matters very informative, clear, on point and commercial.’

‘Stephen Barry is the standout individual that we worked with. Responsive, determined, calm, he quickly became a trusted adviser. He understands our values, our risk appetite and gives practical advice. A brilliant communicator and very sharp on strategy and negotiation.

Kernmandanten

RWE Renewables


Ventaway Limited


Cuilfeach Teoranta


KC Capital Property Group Limited


Electrical Pump Services Limited


Westridge Limited


Orsted


Veolia Water Ireland Limited


Statkraft Ireland Limited


Mercroft Taverns Limited


Enercon GmBH


Compass Data Centres


Regan Wall


Armstrong Planning


ES UK


Vantage DC


Pure DC


Richmond Homes


Hibernia Reit Plc


Kingspan Holdings (Ireland) Limited


Dublin Port Company


Dublin Airport Authority


Ashbourne Meats


Ballynagran Landfill Limited


Knockharley Landfill Limited


Black Lough Wind Farm Limited


Enros Wind Farm Limited


Allied Irish Banks, p.l.c.


Highlight-Mandate


  • Acting for Dublic Airport Authority (daa), as the operator of Dublin Airport, in High Court proceedings concerning claims that councillors acted unlawfully in prescribing aircraft noise mitigation measures that could cost daa some €1.8 billion.
  • Advising a group of shareholders (Yellow River Windfarm Limited) in a Commercial Court action against SSE Renewables relating to the interpretation of an agreement and payment terms for the construction of a windfarm incorporating 29 wind turbines.
  • Advising Kingspan in an investigatory review of compliance and governance in the UK Insulation Boards business arising from its participation as a core participant in the UK’s Grenfell Tower Inquiry and identifying recommendations for implementation.

Mason Hayes & Curran LLP

The planning and environment team at Mason Hayes & Curran LLP regularly advises clients on the environmental aspects of high-profile infrastructure projects under development in Ireland, including significant offshore and terrestrial projects, and stands out for its work in contributing to the country’s climate transition. Deirdre Nagle heads the team and her extensive expertise includes assisting clients with the planning and environmental side of major state infrastructure projects. Another notable contact is Jay Sattin, who assists with both contentious and non-contentious environmental and related matters.

Praxisleiter:

Deirdre Nagle


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Jay Sattin; Grainne Tiernan


Referenzen

‘The planning and environment team at Mason Hayes & Curran have been a strong support. The team has been on hand to guide us through some complex issues, particularly in the areas of planning and zoning of residential land.’

‘The team is very knowledgeable and responsive to requests about Irish law and EU law more broadly. They are particularly well versed in the environmental, health and safety space (EHS).’

‘We appreciate their attention to detail, their responsiveness and flexibility when it comes to time-sensitive issues, and their breadth of knowledge about the EHS space.’

Kernmandanten

Uisce Eireann


EirGrid


SSE Renewables


FuturEnergy


Orsted


EDF Renewables


Highlight-Mandate


  • Acting for FuturEnergy Ireland in judicial review proceedings over the refusals for Croaghaun Windfarm and Cahermurphy Two Windfarms, which were conceded by the respondent, An Bord Pleanála, and the planning applications were remitted to be reconsidered.
  • Advising SSE on all aspects of the planning and foreshore consents, both onshore and offshore, which are required to build out the Arklow Bank Offshore Wind Farm.
  • Lead advisor for EirGrid on its strategic infrastructure development application for the 400 kV Kildare Meath transmission upgrade project.

William Fry LLP

William Fry LLP‘s environment and planning team regularly advises clients on energy transition projects, as well as on infrastructure projects more broadly. Notably, it has recently been assisting with the environmental issues arising from the development of major data centres. Michelle Martin specialises in planning and environment-related judicial reviews and the handling of EPA prosecutions.

Weitere Kernanwälte:

Kate Abell; Michelle Martin


Referenzen

‘The teamwork is very effective for heavy planning and environmental cases.’

‘Kate Abell is extremely bright and takes the initiative in identifying potential grounds of challenge in judicial review.’

‘This team hold their own with other similarly placed planning and environmental law teams operating in the Dublin and Irish market. The team possess a great knowledge of the legal code and, as such, are able to advise clients in a strategic, solution-oriented manner. Their approach to detail is impressive’

Kernmandanten

Aughinish Alumina Limited


Fingal County Council


Diageo


Tirlán (formerly Glanbia)


Tesco Ireland Limited


Uniphar Plc


Poundland Limited t/a Dealz


Towercom Limited


EirGrid Plc


EngineNode Limited


Digital Realty Trust


LCC Group Limited


Art Data Centres Limited


Mid-Cork Pallets & Packaging Limited


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advising EirGrid plc, the Irish state-owned electric power transmission operator, in relation to a proposed emergency development of additional electricity generation capacity to secure supply.
  • Advising Fingal County Council on all planning and environmental law aspects of a major flagship development project, the proposed Swords Cultural Quarter, and acting for the Council in an oral hearing held by An Bord Pleanála in respect of a related CPO.
  • Representing Art Data Centres Limited in the defence of a high-profile judicial review challenge to the granting of permission for the construction of a strategic data centre valued in excess of €1.2 billion.

Addleshaw Goddard

The planning, infrastructure, and consenting team at Addleshaw Goddard is headed by Margaret Austin, who acts for individuals and corporate clients in various stages of environmental planning processes, whether as applicants or objectors. The team regularly advises clients on complying with environmental and planning legislation, and represents them in related court proceedings arising from the planning process.

Praxisleiter:

Margaret Austin


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Kate Liddy-Cormican


Referenzen

‘The team has an excellent knowledge of our industry.’

‘They really care about us as a client – always available and respond promptly. Both Margaret Austin and Kate Liddy-Cormican are exceptional people to deal with.’

Highlight-Mandate


Byrne Wallace Shields LLP

Byrne Wallace Shields‘s environment and planning practice group stands out for its expertise in waste management, contaminated land, and environmental due diligence matters. Heading the team is Valerie Hourigan, who regularly represents clients in the environmental sector in complex litigation, particularly in judicial review proceedings.

Praxisleiter:

Valerie Hourigan


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Mona Costelloe


Referenzen

‘The team was always available for clarification on any issues of concern.’

‘The P&E team are very informative and provide a step-by-step guide to the legal processes surrounding planning and environmental issues.’

‘Valerie Hourigan provided excellent guidance through a judicial review process. The guidance from Valerie and the team was invaluable. In addition, the papers produced were excellent and their handling of the court process superb.’

Kernmandanten

An Bord Pleanála


Environmental Protection Agency


Inland Fisheries Ireland


Deposit Return Scheme Ireland CLG


Red Rock Donnybrook Limited


Lidl Ireland GmbH


Fáilte Ireland


Highlight-Mandate


  • Acting for An Bord Pleanála in the defence of judicial review proceedings.
  • Acting for Inland Fisheries Ireland in successful High Court judicial review proceedings in which IFI challenged a decision of the Aquaculture Licences Appeals Board to grant an aquaculture licence for the cultivation of Atlantic salmon.
  • Advised Deposit Return Scheme Ireland CLG, trading as Re-Turn, in relation to the Deposit Return Scheme.

RDJ LLP

The team at RDJ LLP has experience in advising clients on complying with complex planning and environmental obligations. Finola McCarthy heads the team and stands out for her work assisting both private and public sector clients across a number of waste sector issues.

Praxisleiter:

Finola McCarthy


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Donal Twomey


Referenzen

‘The firm’s planning and environment practice brings a deep and longstanding expertise in both non-contentious and contentious matters combined with sound judgment that keeps clients between the ditches.’

‘Finola McCarthy, dealing with both contentious and non-contentious matters, and Donal Twomey on the contentious side are stars. Both are highly intelligent with calm, rational and very pleasant personalities, unafraid of complex legal and factual scenarios, and always focused on the client’s best interests.’

Kernmandanten

MWB Two Limited


Reside Capital Limited


Sir Charles Colthurst, Blarney Castle Estates


Byrne Looby


Donegal County Council/Roads Management Office


AWN Consulting


Trinity College Dublin


Hamwood Stud


Kenny Group


BMOR Construction


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advising MWB Two Limited on a strategic housing development (SHD) pursuant to the Planning and Development Act.
  • Acting for Reside Capital/Hallmark Developments in a significant judicial review challenge taken against its multimillion-euro SHD by Peter Sweetman.
  • Acted for Byrne Looby in the successful defence of a prosecution brought by Inland Fisheries Ireland arising out of a fish kill in the River Bandon in May 2017 during dredging works.