EU and competition in Scotland

Brodies LLP

Entrusted by significant multinational corporates and regional and international authorities, Brodies LLP’s key strengths lie in handling a broad spectrum of contentious and non-contentious EU and competition law matters. The firm is also recognised for its expertise in subsidy control mandates. The practice is led by Charles Livingstone, whose work spans international merger control issues, antitrust compliance and enforcement work, competition litigation, and market investigations. Christine O’Neill is highly regarded for her expertise in transport infrastructure and competition-related matters, while Jamie Dunne is a go-to adviser for both bidders and public bodies on public procurement issues.

Praxisleiter:

Charles Livingstone


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Christine O’Neill; Jamie Dunne


Referenzen

‘The team is approachable, knowledgeable, and very efficient – just what is needed.’

‘Brodies LLP have delivered legal support and services to our organisation and extended membership in a collaborative manner, flexing to our often changing demands, in a professional, supportive, and collaborative manner.’

‘Jamie Dunne has excellent professionalism in delivering our requirement.’

Kernmandanten

The Scotch Whisky Association


The University of Edinburgh


James Jones & Sons Limited


AGS Airports Limited


Scottish Futures Trust


Scottish Enterprise


Highlands & Islands Enterprise


Falkirk Council


Stornoway Port Authority


Stream Marine Training


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advised the Scotch Whisky Association on various competition matters, including reviewing the SWA’s policy and controls on the collation of member information.
  • Assisted APCOA Parking (UK) Limited with a number of procurement challenges to local authority decisions and processes.
  • Advised Falkirk Council, as lead authority for the Forth Green Freeport, on the application of subsidy control legislation to the Freeport.

Dentons

Dentons’ competition team has a strong track record in guiding clients through the full life cycle of competition law matters. With robust experience across both contentious and non-contentious work, the team works with clients from a wide range of sectors, including the energy, retail, manufacturing, transport, and financial services spaces. Keys services include advice on merger control, foreign direct investment, dawn raid compliance, subsidy control, and public procurement. Michael Dean, who is vastly experienced in all facets of competition law, from dawn raids and cartel investigations to merger clearances and vertical agreements, heads the practice. Melanie Martin leads on non-contentious competition matters and subsidy control issues, while Carolyn Burns is a trusted adviser to clients across both public and private sector mandates.

Praxisleiter:

Michael Dean


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Melanie Martin; Carolyn Burns


Referenzen

‘Carolyn Burns provides deep experience, drawing upon expertise to provide pragmatic and real-world advice, customised to our business needs.’

‘Dentons have a strong competition practice. As well as providing us with high-quality advice on a range of matters, the team are very proactive in promoting learning and development opportunities.’

‚Michael Dean is a leader in his field, providing technical advice targeted to the context of the business.‘

Kernmandanten

Stagecoach Group


Merck KGaA


Mercedes-Benz Group AG


UK Government


Storegga


KPS Capital Partners LP


Menzies Aviation


The Edrington Group Limited


Alexander Dennis


Manolo Blahnik


Highlight-Mandate


  • Represented SSWT in the first standalone collective proceedings in the UK, securing a precedent-setting settlement without liability.
  • Advised the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero on the new regulatory regime for the new Independent System Operator and Planner and the acquisition of National Grid Electricity System Operator Limited to form the new entity, now known as NESO.
  • Advised Mercedes-Benz Group AG on the first follow-on claims brought in Scotland, which relate to the European Commission’s Trucks decision.

Burness Paull LLP

Burness Paull LLP’s practice advises its portfolio of clients on the full range of EU and competition law, covering both contentious and non-contentious matters, from public procurement work to subsidy control issues. Colin Miller oversees the team and has substantial experience in handling investigations being carried out by the Competition and Markets Authority and the European Commission. Graeme Palmer offers particular insight into the utilities sector, while Ruth McNaught specialises in procurement litigation.

Praxisleiter:

Colin Miller


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Graeme Palmer; Ruth McNaught


Referenzen

‘Colin Miller is well respected in the market.’

‘Colin Miller provided excellent support on competition law matters. His advice was clear, commercial and pragmatic. He is easy to deal with and responsive.’

Kernmandanten

Lindal Dispenser GmbH


South Lanarkshire Council


Scottish Football Association share


Shareholders of Flexebee


GBUK


Zoetis


Highland Spring


Scottish Enterprise


Highlands and Islands Enterprise


Cromarty First Port Authority


Highlight-Mandate


  • Represented Lindal Dispenser GmbH in defence of a Scottish court action relating to alleged patent infringement by the client, which manufactures applicators and dispensers.
  • Advised Cromarty Firth Port Authority on its successful application for a grant of £55.7m from the UK Government Department for Energy Security and Net Zero’s Floating Offshore Wind Manufacturing Investment Scheme.
  • Represented the SFA, the governing body for football in Scotland, in a complaint to the CMA about its rules for registering young players at elite clubs and transferring them between clubs.

CMS

CMS has established a strong foothold in the Scottish market, providing comprehensive support to clients on competition and regulatory investigations, merger control issues, and subsidy control work. Graeme Young, whose workload spans competition compliance, commercial agreements, and investigations, heads the practice. Wendy Nicolson is frequently sought out by clients for assistance with public procurement and competition matters. Emma Blundell and Liam Maclean are also recommended.

Praxisleiter:

Graeme Young


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Wendy Nicolson; Emma Blundell; Liam Maclean


Referenzen

‘The team understands our organisation. CMS provides commercial, pragmatic and tailored advice. The team is particularly responsive, and we know we can rely on them to turn around complex matters quickly and efficiently.’

‘Graeme Young is excellent. He translates complex concepts effectively and is at the cutting edge of his practice. He has built strong relationships at various levels in our organisation and is trusted to provide credible and pragmatic advice.’

‚The team is capable of understanding complex, specialist business areas so that it can apply it’s advice in context and with market understanding.‘

Kernmandanten

Leicester City Football Club


NatWest Group Plc


BP Plc


Dye & Durham Corporation


National Grid


NHS Scotland / NSS


NI Water


South of Scotland Enterprise


Highland and Islands Enterprise


Scottish National Investment Bank


Ringway


University of Glasgow


IQVIA


Scottish Power


MetLife


Gridserve


Dumfries & Galloway Council


Smart DCC


Toyota Financial Services


Places for People Leisure Management Limited


ISS UK


NeuConnect


Atos UK


University of Sheffield


BAE Systems


Phoenix Group


Venterra PLC


EV Holdings


Rothesay Life PLC


Cicor Technologies


Abbott Laboratories


Medtronic


Haemonetics


Scottish Government


Unum Group


Scottish Water


Producers Alliance for Cinema and Television


Highlight-Mandate


  • Assisted Phoenix Group with its joint venture with Schroders to form Future Growth Capital.
  • Assisted Venterra Group PLC, an offshore wind services business, with the acquisition of Oceanscan Holdings Limited and associated equity and debt fundraisings.

Shepherd and Wedderburn

Shepherd and Wedderburn handles all aspects of competition law work, including procurements, domestic and European investigations, subsidy control issues and transactional work. The group’s workload is spread across the utilities, renewables, infrastructure and energy sectors, with key clients including local Scottish authorities and sports governing bodies. Gordon Downie steers the group and has focused his practice on competition law and regulations in the regulated sector. John MacKenzie specialises in competition damages actions, while Scott Rodger is well-versed in assisting with energy regulation, procurement, and NSI Act matters; Jamie McRorie is also a key contact for energy and utility sector regulation mandates.

Praxisleiter:

Gordon Downie


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Scott Rodger; John MacKenzie; Natasha Durkin; Jamie McRorie


Referenzen

‘We are working mainly with Gordon Downie who puts us in relation with other members of the firm when needed. We can recommend Gordon Downie, John MacKenzie, Scott Rodger, Natasha Durkin and Jamie McRorie.’

Kernmandanten

Offshore Renewable Energy Catapult


Energy Transition Zone


Scottish National Investment Bank


Epic Games


Dumfries and Galloway Council


Single Electricity Market Committee


Bluefloat Nadara Partnership


ScottishPower


Anderson Strathern

Anderson Strathern stands out for its deep-rooted expertise in competition disputes, subsidy regulation, and broader antitrust advisory work, especially within the public sector. The practice demonstrates particular strength in representing clients before the Court of Session, Commercial Court, and the Competition Appeal Tribunal. Practice head Katrina Lumsdaine is known for her longstanding experience in handling competition litigation, while Douglas McLachlan is singled out for his investigation work. Eilidh MacEwan is also noted for her expertise in this area.

Praxisleiter:

Katrina Lumsdaine


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Douglas McLachlan; Eilidh MacEwan


Referenzen

‘Anderson Strathern are our legal advisers. Their advice has been first-rate. Katrina Lumsdaine has provided clear and practical advice. She is ably supported by her team, who have done good work crunching the details of the claim.‘

‚Katrina Lumsdaine has led the case and been a reassuring and authoritative presence. Eilidh MacEwan has supported Katrina and provided clear research and analysis.’

Kernmandanten

Scottish Local Authorities and Scottish Water


Aberdeenshire Council; Argyll & Bute Council; East Renfrewshire; and South Lanarkshire Council


Grahams The Family Dairy Limited; Graham’s Dairies Limited, Grahams The Family Dairy (Processing) Limited


Allied Vehicles Limited


The Skills Development Scotland Company Limited


John Martin Group Limited


Edinburgh Napier University


Highlight-Mandate


  • Assisted 22 Public Bodies with the damages on behalf of 22 public bodies‘ actions arising out of a Truck Cartel.
  • Advised John Martin Group Limited on the compatibility of dealer and manufacturer agreements with The Competition Act 1998.
  • Advised SDS (Scotland’s National Skills body) that supports the people and businesses of Scotland on the Subsidy Control Act 2023.

Harper Macleod LLP

Harper Macleod LLP serves a distinguished client base from both the public and private sectors. The team provides day-to-day advice across all aspects of competition law, with a particular focus on public procurement and subsidy control work. In addition to this, the practice regularly handles merger control issues, anti-competitive practice work, and abuse of dominance cases. James McMorrow provides strategic guidance to clients on subsidy control, public procurement, and competition law matters. Wendy Richardson is a key contact for public law issues, and Donnie Munro leads the practice.

Praxisleiter:

Donnie Munro


Weitere Kernanwälte:

James McMorrow; Wendy Richardson


Referenzen

‘The availability of the individual team members is excellent – you can always rely on a quick response to initial contacts and regular updates.’

‘Procurement advice, very practical, up to date and accurate.’

‘James McMorrow has a very sound commercial sense and is extremely well versed in the relevant law.’

Kernmandanten

Scottish Government


Glasgow City Council


City of Edinburgh Council


Inverclyde Council


Cairngorms National Park Authority


NatureScot


Scottish Fire and Rescue


Forestry and Land Scotland


Orkney Islands Council


Scottish Courts and Tribunal Service


Fife Council


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advised Orkney Islands Council on the Scapa Deep Water Quay Project, an infrastructure project valued at £200m+.
  • Represented SalMar ASA on its defence of high-value and high-profile proceedings arising out of the alleged Norwegian salmon cartel.
  • Advised Inverclyde Council on the Inverkip City Region Deal Project in partnership with Scottish Power/Iberdrola.

Morton Fraser MacRoberts

Morton Fraser MacRoberts offers proactive support in mitigating the issues linked to mergers, acquisitions, and joint ventures, as well as subsidy control and public procurement work. Beyond this, the firm assists clients from the energy, infrastructure, healthcare, and food and drink sectors on competition law matters. Practice head Robin Fallas stands out in the transport sector, serving as a key adviser to companies navigating commercial contracts, procurement processes, and compliance with UK and EU law on public projects.

Praxisleiter:

Robin Fallas


Referenzen

‘The company has worked with MFM in this area for many years, and they have consistently shown a high degree of knowledge and expertise.’

‘MFM has managed to retain their advisory team throughout the many years of working together, and as such, the institutional and retained knowledge greatly assists with providing additional advice.’

‚They have consistently shown a high degree of knowledge and expertise.‘

Kernmandanten

Scottish Ministers


Student Loans Company


Scottish Government


Scottish Water


Scottish and Southern Energy


Transport Scotland


City of Edinburgh Council


Western Ferries


Historic Environment Scotland


Hydrogen Vehicle Systems Ltd


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advised Rocep-Lusol Holdings Limited on a commercial action in the Court of Session against Lindal Dispenser GmbH.
  • Advised a public body on competition litigation.
  • Advised a public body on detailed and complex subsidy control considerations relevant to a new scheme.