Hall Of Fame

Professional negligence in Scotland

Brodies LLP

The professional risk team at Brodies LLP is notable for its ‘top-rate expertise’ and ‘reassuring strength of knowledge’. Led by Alan Calvert, the team’s well-deserved reputation attracts a diverse array of clients from across the country. Calvert is a major presence in the area, with over thirty years of experience in construction, commercial and financial disputes. Alisdair Matheson has strong experience in the insurance industry and also provides counsel for professionals in the construction space. With experience in commercial litigation, Laura Fell also provides support across the firm’s professional negligence work, as does James Jerman.

Praxisleiter:

Alan Calvert


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Alisdair Matheson; Laura Fell; James Jerman


Referenzen

‘The strength of knowledge the team has is very reassuring. Professional negligence claims are a very concerning situation for a business but Brodies‘ expertise helps us feel reassured we have assistance from a great team.’

‘Alan Calvert is excellent and happy to talk us through the process and alleviate any concerns. Good practical advice.

‘The Brodies Team, including Laura Fell, were excellent throughout the case. They conducted thorough research and consulted with us, keeping us informed throughout the process. Their position was robust and their defence well-presented and strong. Overall we received a very professional hands-on service that reassured us from start to finish.‘

Kernmandanten

RSA


Aviva


MS Amlin


Axa XL


Allianz


Aspen Insurance UK Ltd


Axis


Arch Insurance Company


Sompo/Endurance


International General Insurance Co Ltd


Starr Insurance


Assured Partners Inc


CNA Hardy


CGPA Europe


Harper Macleod LLP

Praised for its ‘deep knowledge base’ and ‘determination’, the team at Harper Macleod LLP is singled out by clients as leader in the field. The firm has extensive experience across a broad range of industries, with teams in Edinburgh and Glasgow, led by Sandy Hastie and David Kerr respectively. The team regularly handles high-value cases in the banking, finance, and insurance spaces. Key members of the team include E-Ming Fong, who provides global commercial litigation expertise, and John McHugh, who has over 25 years of experience. Andrew MacKenzie supports the team, and Adam de Ste Croix is also a notable figure.

Praxisleiter:

Sandy Hastie; David Kerr


Weitere Kernanwälte:

E-Ming Fong; John McHugh; Andrew MacKenzie; Adam de Ste Croix


Referenzen

‘Harper Macleod is stacked with talented people. They have real strength in depth, which means they are able to resource and run the biggest litigation in Scotland with ease. One of their key capabilities is their first-class ability to manage litigation of any size.’

‚All of the individuals I have dealt with are knowledgeable, diligent and professional. They take great care in explaining detailed legal matters so that they are fully and properly understood.‘

‘David Kerr is a partner in the team. He stands out as being an extremely tough litigator. He always fights his client’s corner with 100% whilst simultaneously being able to deliver trusted advice to them about the reality of litigation. Andrew Mackenzie’s key qualities are the intelligence he brings to bear on any litigation in which he is involved. He thinks about all of the angles and really seeks to maximise every point in his client’s favour.‘

Kernmandanten

Nike


Halfords Group


Renault


Harris Tweed Hebrides Limited


Scania


B&M Retail Limited


Optical Express Group


Nero Holdings Limited


Greenpeace


SalMar


Highlight-Mandate


  • Acted for a client in a $350m action against the purchasers of his shareholding in an oil & gas company and their solicitors based on an unlawful means conspiracy.
  • Successfully represented Centenary 6 Ltd at proof (trial) in a £40m loss of opportunity claim against solicitors, concerning legal advice given which resulted in the irretrievable loss of a prior right of action.
  • Advised Hillhouse Quarry Group Limited on its defence to a Court of Session claim by Lagan Asphalt (UK) Limited.

Beale & Co

Formerly of DWF, the professional negligence team at Beale & Co is headed by Lindsay Ogunyemi and Andrew McConnell, who are highly regarded in the market. The pair provide key advice to important clients in the insurance and construction sectors, assisting with high-value matters with a particular focus on professional indemnity insurance cases. Alongside Ogunyemi and McConnell, key contacts in the team who regularly provide support are Eileen Sherry and Iain Franklin.

Praxisleiter:

Lindsay Ogunyemi; Andrew McConnell


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Eileen Sherry; Iain Franklin


Kernmandanten

Aviva


Arup


AtkinsRealis


RSA


Arthur J Gallagher


Galliford Try


CNA Hardy


QBE


RSA


BTO Solicitors LLP

The team at BTO Solicitors LLP provides expert advice on complex professional negligence claims across a wide variety of industries, focusing on the construction and engineering spaces. Practice head Tim Edward has a wealth of experience in professional negligence issues, and clients singled him out as 'an outstanding litigator'. Supporting him in the team is Sian Keddie, who has handled a range of cases, and is ‘thorough’ and ’empathetic’ according to the firm’s clients.

Praxisleiter:

Tim Edward


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Sian Keddie


Referenzen

‘Tim Edward is very good at building a team of people who gel well and all know the direction of travel.’

‘Tim Edward is very good at seeing the bigger picture and knows how to handle challenging clients.‘

‘I have been impressed by their grasp of the issues our complex case posed.’

Kernmandanten

Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance


Aviva Insurance


Allianz Insurance


AIG Insurance


TUV SUD Limited


Highlight-Mandate


  • Acting for TUV SUD Limited and its insurers in relation to multi-million pound claims arising from projects for the construction of the RHCYP/DCN in Edinburgh and the QEUH in Glasgow, including representation in the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry and in Court of Session litigation.
  • Acting for engineers and their insurers in a multi-million pound claim arising from the design of harbour works at a Scottish port.
  • Acting for engineers and insurers in a multi-million pound claim arising from cladding design work including representation at mediation and in Court.

Burness Paull LLP

With strong experience in professional negligence cases, the team at Burness Paull LLP provides support to a variety of clients across the construction, insurance, and financial sectors. Ashley Jones leads the team and has extensive litigation experience, and regularly advises on high-value, complex disputes. Louise McDaid contributes her commercial expertise, and Meriel Miller and Mhairi Morrison are other key names to note.

Praxisleiter:

Ashley Jones


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Louise McDaid; Meriel Miller; Mhairi Morrison


Referenzen

‘I would class the lawyers I have dealt with to be at the top of their game in their respective fields. The firm commands a reputation, such that any legal team on the other side of the table knows they are going to have to be at their very best to stand a chance.’

‘From day 1, Ashley Jones grasped the issues and was able to explain how the case would pan out. She provided the right amount of engagement and did exactly what she said she would do.’

‘Ashley Jones is fantastic – excellent all round skill set including legal knowledge, judgment and client relationships. Mhairi Morrison is a standout associate. Forensic examination of the factual and legal issues with good judgment.‘

Clyde & Co

The team at Clyde & Co provides support to a variety of clients across the construction and financial sectors. Sarah Crewes is a stand-out figure, noted for her litigation experience and her 'fantastic client care'. She is ably supported by Beverley Atkinson who, according to clients, is 'a real asset to the team, and very easy to deal with'.

Praxisleiter:

Sarah Crewes


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Beverley Atkinson


Referenzen

‘In all of my interaction with Clyde & Co, I have always found them to be a very accessible and approachable firm who consistently deliver a diligent and reliable professional service.’

‘My dealings with Clyde & Co have always been with highly professional, attentive and knowledgeable individuals. A special mention goes to Sarah Crewes and her team – they consistently deliver and always in a friendly manner.’

‘A team which is highly experienced and very well regarded – Beverley Atkinson is a real specialist in her field. If you’re facing a professional indemnity claim, you’d want her in your corner. She works exceptionally hard for her clients.’

CMS

The professional indemnity team at CMS offers ‘a high degree of expertise’ and is situated within the firm’s larger insurance group. Specialising in construction, renewable energy, and finance sector issues, the team is co-led by Harriet Munro, who provides ‘robust and practical advice’, and Graeme MacLeod, who has notable commercial expertise. Another key contact within the team is Rowena Williams, who is ‘extremely knowledgeable’ in insurance litigation.

Praxisleiter:

Harriet Munro; Graeme MacLeod


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Rowena Williams


Referenzen

‘A very high degree of expertise in insurance based litigation.‘

‘Both Harriet Munro and Rowena Williams are extremely knowledgeable on insurance related litigation and provide robust and practical advice.’

‚Harriet Munro is a stand-out partner – with her experience of insurance litigation in London, has a rare appreciation for the pure insurance aspects. Rowena Williams is an outstanding associate and a star of the future.‘

Kernmandanten

QBE


Markel International


AIG


RSA


Riverstone (formerly Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance Group)


AXIS (formerly Novae Group plc)


Liberty Syndicate


AXA XL (formerly XL Catlin)


WR Berkley


Munich Re


WSP


Green Cat Renewables


Highlight-Mandate


  • Acted for the defender – a global firm of engineers – in a high-profile dispute concerning the impact of remediation of brownfield sites.
  • Acted for a Scottish law firm in a $300m conspiracy to defraud claim.
  • Acted for multidisciplinary engineering consultancy WSP in relation to various issues arising from the development of the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow which are the subject of multiple court actions (with claims totalling £80m+) and an ongoing public inquiry.

Kennedys

Providing ‘excellent service’, the team at Kennedys regularly advises on high-value matters in the construction space, particularly alleged defect claims. The team is led by Gavin Henderson, who clients praise as ‘highly professional and a calm authority'. Anne Kentish is another key contact in the team; she routinely works on complex cases, notably claims involving legal professionals.

Praxisleiter:

Gavin Henderson


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Anne Kentish; Peter Demick; David Nelson; Colette Finnieston


Referenzen

‘I have worked mainly with Anne Kentish and Colette Finnieston. Both know professional negligence work inside out and provide an excellent service to their clients. Would strongly recommend. They fight their client’s corner well while giving pragmatic advice on settlement where needed.’

‘David Nelson has excellent attention to detail and highly professional. Excellent to work with.‘

‚Gavin Henderson is highly professional and a calm authority.‘

Kernmandanten

QBE


Aye Waste Management Limited


Glasgow School of Art


Hulley & Kirkwood


Prater Ltd / Lindner Fassaden GMBH


Aviva


Allan Murray Architects


Turner & Townsend


KKA


Royal & Sun Alliance


CCDP LLP


Ogilvie Homes


Highlight-Mandate


  • Acting for Building Design Partnership (BDP) in a claim brought by Leonardo Hotel Management (UK) Limited against BDP and also Galliford Try Building 2014 Limited arising from the construction of a hotel at Union Square in Aberdeen.
  • Instructed to investigate and pursue claims against a number of parties in connection with the June 2018 fire at the Glasgow School of Art’s Mackintosh Building.

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

With a ‘high degree of knowledge’, the team at DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP regularly deals with complex disputes, particularly focusing on construction disputes and providing counsel for professionals, including solicitors. Team leader Jilly Petrie consistently advises on construction disputes and has decades of experience in the insurance sector. Other key members of the team include Alan Eadie, Matthew Raftery and Lynne Cardow.

Praxisleiter:

Jilly Petrie


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Alan Eadie; Lynne Cardow; Matthew Raftery


Referenzen

‘In-depth practical and hands-on knowledge of the insurance industry and insurance law within the construction sector.’

‘Jilly Petrie is client-focused and commercial, meaning she prepares for the worst but looks for outcomes which maintain relationships between all parties.’

‘Lynne Cardow and Alan Eadie are both very experienced professional negligence solicitors with excellent market reputations.’

Kernmandanten

QBE Insurance


Zurich Insurance PLC


Tokio Marine HCC


AmTrust


HSB Engineering Insurance Limited


Aviva


AIG


AXA XL


RSA Group


TLT

The professional negligence team at TLT has key expertise in the financial services sector, with particular focus on residential lender claims. The team provides ‘quality advice’ and is led by John Paul Sheridan, who has over 25 years of experience in the field and is praised by clients for his ‘exceptional understanding of complex details’. Louise Chopra is another key team member and is an experienced litigator.

Praxisleiter:

John Paul Sheridan


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Louise Chopra


Referenzen

‘The experience is enhanced on account of the personal attention to detail once the information has been filtered through to John Paul Sheridan. It is comforting to have very technical points explained in simple terms.’

‘John Paul Sheridan has an exceptional understanding of complex details that allows him to simplify better than most.’

‘The team has one of the most extensive professional negligence practices in Scotland and is able to provide quality advice on negligence in many professional fields.’