In addition to representing clients from energy-intensive industries and the infrastructure sector, Gleiss Lutz has extensive experience in advising the public sector. The team assists numerous German state governments and various federal ministries with various state aid issues. This includes, among other matters, support for M&A transactions, capital injections, privatisations and remunicipalisations as well as compliance issues under subsidy and state aid law. The semiconductor industry represents another focus: Led by practice head and expert in European state aid law Ulrich Soltész, the team is involved in numerous major projects within the framework of the European Chips Act. Counsel Harald Weiß has extensive expertise across the full spectrum of German and European competition law, in particular in antitrust law, cartel damages, merger control and EU state aid law.
State aid in Germany
Gleiss Lutz
Praxisleiter:
Ulrich Soltész
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Jacob von Andreae; Christian von Köckritz; Harald Weiß; Eva Koch
Referenzen
‘Gleiss Lutz has an excellent state aid team that is always available and senior people strike a perfect balance between appropriate attention to detail and strategic overview.’
‘Ulrich Soltész is a leader in the field of state aid – an encyclopedia of legal developments and case law.’
‘Harald Weiss is a true talent in the field of state aid – a leader of the future.’
‘Gleiss Lutz is clearly the German-speaking No. 1 in EU state aid law. We use their expertise for EU state aid law support/second opinions.’
‘Excellent legal expertise, very solution-oriented and always able to put oneself in client’s shoes. The processing deadlines were always met.’
‘Ulrich Soltész is an outstanding lawyer. He is extremely competent, always approachable and very responsive. You can see that he is willing to go the extra mile for the interests of his clients. He also manages to present complex issues in a comprehensible manner. On a personal level, he is also very friendly and empathetic.’
‘Excellent collaboration with Ulrich Soltész and Harald Weiß. Both know what they are talking about. Client-oriented, pragmatic.’
Kernmandanten
Apollo Management Holdings L.P.
DB Cargo AG
Deutsche Telekom AG
Freistaat Bayern
Infineon Technologies AG
KPS Capital Partners
Robert Bosch GmbH / Infineon Technologies AG / NXP Semiconductors N.V.
Rolls-Royce Deutschland Ltd. & Co. KG
STEAG
voestalpine AG
Highlight-Mandate
- Regulatory advice to KPS Capital Partners on the acquisition of the global electric motor business of Innomotics GmbH from Siemens AG with an enterprise value of €3.5 billion.
- State aid advice for Robert Bosch GmbH, Infineon Technologies AG and NXP Semiconductors NV on a joint investment in the joint venture European Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (ESMC) GmbH for semiconductor production in Dresden. The project is planned within the framework of the European Chips Act.
- Representation of the Free State of Bavaria in proceedings before European courts regarding the action against the EU Commission’s recovery decision for allegedly inadmissible aid in connection with the financing of milk quality tests. The proceedings before the Commission were successfully concluded in 2024 (termination of the investigation procedure).
Redeker Sellner Dahs
Redeker Sellner Dahs' expertise in funding and state aid law is routinely applied to advise numerous companies in the energy sector as well as federal and state ministries, municipalities and public bodies. It focuses on major restructurings, crisis cases and future topics such as the green transformation, renewable energies and sustainability. Alongside practice head Andreas Rosenfeld, who specialises in EU state aid procedures for the rescue and restructuring of banks and counts aid providers and aid recipients among his clients, Clemens Holtmann (state aid law, European law, ESG), who made partner in January 2024, is another key contact.
Praxisleiter:
Andreas Rosenfeld
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Simone Lünenbürger; Clemens Holtmann
Referenzen
‘The advisory approach is careful and thoughtful. They do not take the client’s views into account, but always remain an additional control authority.’
‘Clemens Holtmann: committed, creative, unpretentious and well connected.’
‘Fast and at the same time thorough, pragmatic and goal-oriented.’
Kernmandanten
Condor
BMUV H2Global Stiftung
Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Klimaschutz
Hydrogen Intermediary Network Company (HINT.CO)
Ministry of Mines and Energy of Namibia, gefördert durch die Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ)
Borderstep Institut
Bundesministerium für Ernährung und Landwirtschaft
Deutsche EnergieAgentur DENA
Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau
STRABAG
Daimler Truck
Highlight-Mandate
- Representation of Condor before the General Court/ECJ in actions brought by Ryanair against Commission approval decisions in favour of Condor for restructuring and Covid-19 aid.
- Advising H2Global Foundation and the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Protection on the design of a €3.5 billion subsidy for the production and import of green hydrogen products from third countries and EU states in accordance with state aid and WTO law.
- Advice to BMUV in relation to a framework agreement concerning the ‘Action Programme for Natural Climate Protection’.
Chatham Partners LLP
Chatham Partners LLP's state aid expertise is regularly called upon in state aid review proceedings before the EU Commission and the European Court of Justice, as well as in the private enforcement of state aid law before German courts. The practice regularly advises clients from the infrastructure, real estate, telecommunications and energy sectors; led by founding partner Marco Núñez Müller, the team recently advised numerous airport and seaport operators as well as housing associations on complex state aid issues. Renewable energy projects represent another focus; Christos Paraschiakos is one of the key contacts for this. He is also well versed in advising internationally active companies on European energy and climate law issues.
Praxisleiter:
Marco Núñez Müller
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Christos Paraschiakos
Kernmandanten
Finanzbehörde der Freien und Hansestadt Hamburg
HafenCity Hamburg GmbH
Vodafone SE
LHG Lübecker Hafen-Gesellschaft mbH
Hansestadt Lübeck
Capsitec GmbH
Orsted
GEWOBA AG
FMO Flughafen Münster/Osnabrück
Trianel GmbH
Uniper
Hochtief AG
Highlight-Mandate
- Advising the Finance Authority of the Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg (FHH) on the establishment and operation (from 2025) of the Financial Services Agency AöR (FSA), which is to raise funds on the capital markets for the budget of the FHH and for its more than 350 investment companies.
- State aid advice to HafenCity Hamburg GmbH (HCH), which manages the FHH’s HafenCity special fund and has been selling and developing large areas north and south of the Elbe for around 20 years and selling them to developers, office and housing construction companies, shopping center operators and operators of art infrastructures for the purpose of appropriate development.
- Advice to Vodafone on state aid law in connection with the possible future imposition of a compulsory levy on large Internet users.
CMS
CMS counts various companies from the energy sector among its client base and advises them on the preparation of their state aid strategies, for instance in connection with the green economy transformation or state-funded initiatives. It also applies its state aid expertise to assist public sector clients and recently advised the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Protection on drafting and developing the funding program for climate protection contracts. Practice head Michael Bauer is extensively active in German and European state aid and antitrust law and focuses on energy and transport as well as on state law issues in the restructuring context.
Praxisleiter:
Michael Bauer
Hengeler Mueller
Hengeler Mueller's state aid practice advises on major EU subsidy programs for innovative and security-relevant technologies, in particular in connection with the EU Chips Act and Important Projects of Common European Interest (IPCEIs). It also focuses on assisting large companies that received support from the German government's Economic Stabilisation Fund in connection with the Covid-19 pandemic or the war in Ukraine. Practice head Jan Bonhage advises both companies and the public sector in procurement, review, EU financial control and state aid proceedings and regularly represents them before the courts of the European Union and in proceedings before the European Commission.
Praxisleiter:
Jan Bonhage
Kernmandanten
SGL Carbon
Landwärme
Siemens AG
Peek & Cloppenburg
Tranzept
Kling Automaten
Kapellmann und Partner
In addition to companies in the energy, sports and aviation sectors, Kapellmann und Partner's state aid practice also advises associations and public institutions across all EU law issues. This includes in particular state aid and grant law matters pertaining to transformation and decarbonisation funding, refinancing measures and regulatory issues. The team is led by practice head Robin van der Hout, who specialises in proceedings before the EU courts as well as the European Commission and EU legislative procedures, and also includes EU state aid and funding law expert Christian Wagner and Valentine Lemonnier (in addition to EU state aid law, also antitrust law), who made associate partner in January 2024.
Praxisleiter:
Robin van der Hout
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Christian Wagner; Valentine Lemonnier
Referenzen
‘Specialised team in EU state aid law, based in Brussels and with extensive experience in dealing with EU institutions based there. Good understanding of local needs.’
‘Very competent advice on EU state aid law from Christian Wagner and Valentine Lemonnier. Very personal approach and high response speed; extensive experience through regular advice to public institutions and companies.’
Baker McKenzie
Baker McKenzie advises companies on state aid, grant and funding law, with a particular focus on issues relating to the research and development of new technologies, including projects in the telecommunications sector, as well as in connection with industrial settlement projects. Key contacts include counsel Janet Butler (in addition to subsidy and EU state aid law, also environmental and planning law) and Katharina Weiner, who made partner in July 2024 and is experienced in public transaction law; she advises both internationally active companies and public sector clients on reorganisations, project developments and M&A transactions. State aid and antitrust law expert Andrés Martin-Ehlers left the team in December 2023 and has been self-employed since then. Practice head Marc Gabriel retired at the end of 2024.
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Janet Butler; Katharina Weiner
BLOMSTEIN Rechtsanwälte
BLOMSTEIN Rechtsanwälte frequently advises numerous clients from the industrial, postal and transport services sectors, on state aid issues entailing antitrust, procurement and foreign trade elements. Led by Max Klasse, who is the key contact for the whole array of German and European antitrust law, merger control and EU state aid law, the team demonstrates particular expertise in state aid proceedings in connection with financing, stabilisation and restructuring measures, while also placing a focus on the new Foreign Subsidies Regulation.
Praxisleiter:
Max Klasse
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Ramona Ader
Kernmandanten
Air France
CRRC ZELC
DCM Film Distribution
Patrimonium PrivateEquity
SEFE Securing Energy for Europe
Vodafone
Highlight-Mandate
- Advising SEFE as Monitoring Trustee on the monitoring of the structural commitments arising from the aid decision to recapitalise SEFE with more than €6 billion due to the war against Ukraine; the aim of the aid is to stabilise Germany’s energy supply.
- Advising Air France as monitoring trustee to monitor the structural and behavioural commitments contained in the State aid decision on France’s recapitalisation measures to support Air France in the context of the Covid-19 crisis.
- Advising CRRC ZELC on Foreign Subsidies Regulation.
Dentons
Under the leadership of environmental law expert Ilka Mehdorn, Dentons' state aid practice serves numerous clients from the transport, telecommunications, industry and financial services sectors and represents them in proceedings before national authorities, in notification proceedings before the EU Commission and in court proceedings before the ECJ. In addition, the practice regularly assists with funding agreements, M&A transactions and aid recovery disputes with the public sector. EU state aid expert Matthias Nordmann is considered the key contact for companies and public institutions that require support in proceedings before the EU Commission, national courts and the European Court of Justice.
Praxisleiter:
Ilka Mehdorn
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Matthias Nordmann
Referenzen
‘Matthias Nordmann in particular is a highly valued colleague with extensive experience in EU state aid law. He has many years of expertise, which he always knows how to use in a balancing manner. ‘
Kernmandanten
Aeroground und Flughafen München
Berliner Wasserbetriebe AöR
CDP
Deutsche Vermögensberatung AG
EFN Eifel-Net Internet Provider GmbH
NeXovation Inc.
Sono Motors
Trentino Sviluppo S.p.A.
Verband der Rundholzhändler e.V.
Volotea
goetel GmbH
Stadtwerke Hamm GmbH
Stadtwerke Hürth GmbH
Bundesverband Breitbandkommunikation e.V.
Telkodata GmbH
enercitySoulution GmbH
Highlight-Mandate
- Advising Spanish airline Volotea in a long-running EU state aid case, which was settled in Volotea’s favour before the European Court of Justice and subsequently advising on further steps and in the subsequent cost reimbursement procedure before the European Commission.
- Advising NeXovation Inc. on an important victory before the European Court of Justice, which ruled that the European Commission had wrongly approved the sale of the Nürburgring to the Capricorn Group in 2014 and providing follow-up advice to the client on how to proceed.
- Advising Berliner Wasserbetriebe on closing a financial coverage gap for the operation of a training campus by a subsidiary, including the review of business activities and impacts on cross-border trade.
GvW Graf von Westphalen
Alongside its state aid advice pertaining to energy and climate protection, where the team handles decarbonisation, hydrogen and infrastructure projects among other matters, GvW Graf von Westphalen has additional expertise in the research and development sector as well as the aviation industry. The team is led by state aid and foreign trade lawyer Gerd Schwendinger and also regularly instructed by public sector clients seeking representation in complaints proceedings before the EU Commission and the European Court of Justice.
Praxisleiter:
Gerd Schwendinger
Referenzen
‘Because it is a large law firm, it is possible to work in an interdisciplinary manner within the same firm. This means that legal issues that affect other areas of law can be resolved efficiently within one firm.’
‘The lawyer we were able to work with most of the time was very committed to the matter. He was familiar with the problems of practice and law, which he was able to balance sensitively. A lawyer who was still concerned with providing good service to his clients. He was also able to work well with various people in our company.’
Kernmandanten
Asseco Central Europe, a. s.
BMWK Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Klimaschutz
Dr. Achim Ahrendt als Insolvenzverwalter der Pella Sietas Werft
Flughafen Bremen GmbH
Flughafen Paderborn/Lippstadt GmbH
Freie und Hansestadt Hamburg, Behörde für Wirtschaft und Innovation
Freizeit-Center Albrecht GmbH & Co. KG
H2FLY GmbH
Haar Mecklenburg GmbH & Co. KG
HafenCity Hamburg GmbH
Hamburger Sportbund e.V.
HEAG mobilo GmbH
Hotel Schloss Stolberg Betriebsgesellschaft mbH
IPK GERMANY PROPERTY MAINPARK PROJEKTGESELLSCHAFT mbH
Joby Aero Inc.
Land Nordrhein-Westfalen
Landesbetrieb Wald und Holz Nordrhein-Westfalen
LINDER GmbH
Mahr EDV GmbH
Makea Industries GmbH
Marktgemeinde Großostheim
Max Eberhard & Sohn GmbH
Mitsubishi Heavy Industries EMEA Ltd.
Nahverkehrsservice Sachsen Anhalt GmbH (Nasa GmbH)
Nordzucker AG
Panatlantic
REGIOMED-KLINIKEN GmbH
Rheinisch-Westfälische Technische Hochschule (RWTH) Aachen
Schmidt Kühltransporte Stuttgart GmbH
SNP-Gruppe
Sprinkenhof GmbH
VentusVentures
ViMAP GmbH
ZAL Zentrum für Angewandte Luftfahrtforschung GmbH
Hogan Lovells International LLP
In close cooperation with the antitrust, procurement and public law teams, Hogan Lovells International LLP's state aid practice covers a broad spectrum with particular expertise in state aid law issues concerning stabilisation, financing and funding measures. The team around state aid, antitrust and procurement law expert Marc Schweda is equally experienced in state aid matters relating to future projects in the context of the EU climate protection goals and the Green Deal. Thomas Dünchheim, whose broad expertise covers public commercial law, municipal law, environmental law and construction law, is another key contact.
Praxisleiter:
Marc Schweda
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Thomas Dünchheim
Referenzen
‘Thomas Dünchheim is extremely responsive and is always available at short notice.’
‘The opinions, reports and recommendations demonstrate the highest level of expertise and are extremely practical. Due to his experience, Thomas Dünchheim can offer valuable solutions for practical use.’
‘Thomas Dünchheim is very attentive to his clients and understands what is relevant for the company.’
Kernmandanten
Autobahn Tank & Rast GmbH
Bundesrepublik Deutschland – Finanzagentur GmbH
ETERNA Mode Holding GmbH
Kasseler Verkehrs- und Versorgungs-GmbH
NRW.BANK AöR
Peek & Cloppenburg KG
Rosneft Deutschland GmbH
Stadtwerke Menden GmbH
Luther Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH
In addition to the state aid practice's traditionally strong presence in energy transition matters, where the team assists numerous large energy companies with infrastructure and industrial projects, including pertaining to the coal phase-out, Luther Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft mbH is also increasingly being instructed by clients from the healthcare sector, particularly to advise on hospital financing. Led by EU state aid lawyer Helmut Janssen, the has additional experience in the transport and logistics sector as well as expertise in advising public sector clients on privatisation procedures, which represent the main focus of Ulf-Dieter Pape's work.
Praxisleiter:
Helmut Janssen
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Ulf-Dieter Pape; Stefan Mager
Kernmandanten
Lausitz Energie Kraftwerke AG
SHS – Stahl-Holding-Saar GmbH & Co.KGaA
INEOS Manufacturing Deutschland GmbH
Wepa Deutschland GmbH & Co. KG und |Wepa Papierfabrik Sachsen GmbH
Investitions- und Förderbank Niedersachsen-NBank
Landesnahverkehrsgesellschaft Niedersachsen
Industrie- und Handelskammer für München und Oberbayern
Landkreis Mittelsachsen
Landkreis Nordsachsen
Stadt Köln
Bochumer Veranstaltungs-GmbH
Zoo Hannover GmbH
Land Berlin – Senatsverwaltung für Finanzen
Land Berlin – Senatsverwaltung für Wissenschaft, Gesundheit und Pflege
Kliniken Frankfurt-Main-Taunus GmbH
Stadt Frankfurt am Main
Highlight-Mandate
- Advising the State of Berlin on all state aid aspects concerning the acquisition of GASAG AG and Vattenfall Fernwärme Berlin, the largest district heating network in Western Europe.
- Advice and representation of the State of Berlin in legal proceedings before the Berlin Administrative Court concerning the legality of hospital financing.
- Advising SHS – Stahl-Holding-Saar GmbH & Co.KGaA on its transformation to CO2 neutrality, the largest net-zero project in the European steel industry.
Noerr
Noerr's expertise in advising companies on state aid is regularly applied in matters pertaining to EU green transition objectives, including the promotion of green hydrogen, as well as in digital transformation matters and large electromobility infrastructure projects. The group is further experienced in eligibility issues and foreign subsidies regulation. The practice is led by EU state aid expert Sarah Blazek, who represents clients in various proceedings before the European Commission and the European courts.
Praxisleiter:
Sarah Blazek
Referenzen
‘Sarah Blazek: Very calm, confident and well thought out demeanor. Very extensive expertise even on specific peripheral issues.’
‘The firm is very well connected, including with the relevant national and European authorities. This provides additional legal certainty, particularly in legally complex cases without established case practice. The consultants have a good hands-on mentality and also understand the needs of the business very well.’
‘The work of Sarah Blazek deserves special mention.’
Kernmandanten
Bankenkonsortium bestehend aus ING Bank, Landesbank Hessen-Thüringen, Norddeutsche Landesbank und Agricultural Bank of China
Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Klimaschutz (BMWK)
Condor Flugdienst GmbH
Deutsche Fußball Liga e.V. (DFL) / Fußballverband
Northvolt
Wohnen in Dresden
Highlight-Mandate
- Advising Northvolton the financing of a battery cell factory (Gigafactory) for electric vehicles in Germany with an investment of more than €4.5 billion.
- Representation of Condor Flugdienst GmbH in several disputes with Ryanair before the Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg to challenge the approvals obtained in three parallel previous aid approval procedures.
- Advising the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Protection (BMWK) on the introduction of the electricity price cap and the gas price cap planned by the federal government.
Pinsent Masons Rechtsanwälte Steuerberater Solicitors Partnerschaft mbB
With the addition of a three-strong team from Dentons in January 2024, Pinsent Masons Rechtsanwälte Steuerberater Solicitors Partnerschaft mbB was able to expand its state aid offering: in addition to assisting universities and research institutions with state-aid financed large-scale research projects, in particular concerning climate-neutral industrial transformations - with Anke Empting being the key contact for this - the practice now also handles matters in the infrastructure sector that concern digitalisation and sustainability . Empting jointly heads the practice with EU, procurement and state aid expert Andreas Haak, who joined the team together with Lars Hettich (procurement law) and Barbara Thiemann (EU state aid law). Due to this expansion of expertise, the team now advises not only federal, state and local authorities, but also high-profile national and international companies on the entire spectrum of state aid issues.
Praxisleiter:
Anke Empting; Andreas Haak
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Lars Hettich; Barbara Thiemann
Kernmandanten
adesso SE
BAM – Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und -prüfung
Berliner Senatskanzlei
BTU Brandenburgische Technische Universität
Christian-Albrechts-Universität zu Kiel
Duisburger Hafen AG
enercitySolution GmbH
HMU Health and Medical University Potsdam GmbH
HMU Health and Medical University GmbH
Landesbetrieb Information und Technik Nordrhein-Westfalen
MSB Medical School Berlin
MSH Medical School Hamburg
Papierfabrik Zerkall GmbH und WEPA
Rhein-Kreis Neuss
RWTH Aachen University
SVA System Vertrieb Alexander GmbH (“SVA”)
Technische Universität München
TUM Venture Labs Management gGmbH
Universität des Saarlandes
Universität Siegen
UnternehmerTUM GmbH
Highlight-Mandate
- Advising Duisburger Hafen AG on a structured bidding process for the sale of 22% of shares in Duisburg Gateway Terminal GmbH in accordance with EU state aid law. The DGT will be the largest and first climate-neutral container terminal in the European hinterland in the Port of Duisburg.
- Ongoing advice to RWTH Aachen University and other companies from the private and public sectors on various projects relating to structural change as well as on innovation and digitalisation.
- Advice to Papierfabrik Zerkall GmbH and WEPA on the establishment of the Fiber Innovation Center Zerkall (FIZZ), which was jointly coordinated with Jülich Research Center and is part of the economic and structural program for the Rhineland future region.
Taylor Wessing
In addition to providing advice on state aid and procurement law in the infrastructure sector, which regularly concerns the privatisation and financing of airlines, airports and ports, Taylor Wessing is well versed in advising hospital operators and state and federal ministries on issues relating to the compliance of hospital financing with state aid law; the group is headed by antitrust expert Marco Hartmann-Rüppel. State aid advice in the public finance sector represents another mainstay. Procurement and state aid expert Michael Brüggemann is the key contact for numerous public sector and private company projects, where he advises on research and development aid, funding, grant decisions and grant contracts. He also represents clients before the EU Commission in state aid review, notifications and complaint proceedings, and before EU courts.
Praxisleiter:
Marco Hartmann-Rüppel
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Michael Brüggemann
Referenzen
‘Very detailed state aid expertise.’
‘Michael Brüggemann; very hands-on, comprehensive knowledge of state aid law, pragmatic application to the facts of a case.’
Kernmandanten
Berlin Energie
Flughafen Frankfurt Hahn GmbH
Marienhaus GmbH
Highlight-Mandate
- State aid advice to Flughafen Frankfurt Hahn GmbH in an insolvency context. Conducting a bidding process in accordance with EU state aid law. In addition, advising the insolvency administrator of Flughafen Frankfurt-Hahn GmbH on the conduct of numerous ongoing court proceedings (administrative and civil courts) from a state aid law perspective.
- Procurement and state aid law advice to Marienhaus Group in accordance with the Hospital Future Act; implementation of numerous digitisation projects in more than ten hospitals.
- State aid advice to Berlin Energie on financing the acquisition of the Berlin district heating network.
WilmerHale
WilmerHale advises companies and government institutions on the receipt and granting of state aid and accompanies them in examination procedures of the European Commission as well as in national and European court proceedings. The group is also experienced in representing clients from the public sector as well as the transport, infrastructure and tourism industries in disputes, including complaints proceedings and competitor actions before national and European courts. The team is led by Hans-Georg Kamann, who assists clients with the full spectrum of antitrust, state aid and procurement matters as well as European administrative and constitutional issues.
Praxisleiter:
Hans-Georg Kamann
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Peter Gey
Kernmandanten
European Molecular Biology Laboratory
Jugendherberge Berlin Ostkreuz gGmbH
Land Hessen
Höchster Porzellanmanufaktur (HMdF)
Hessisches Ministerium der Finanzen HmdF (AIQ)
FRS Elbfähre Glückstadt-Wischhafen GmbH
Highlight-Mandate
- State aid advice to FRS Elbfähre Glückstadt-Wischhafen GmbH on the financing of an electric ferry service with four new electric ferries across the Elbe by the states of Lower Saxony and Schleswig-Holstein.
- Advising European Molecular Biology Laboratory on the applicability of EU State aid rules to the activities of this international organisation.
- Merger control, antitrust, state aid, public law and contractual advice to the Hessian Ministry of Finance (HMdF) in connection with the establishment of the AI Quality & Testing Hub (AIQ), a joint venture between the State of Hesse and the Association of the Electrical Industry (VDE), to provide individual advice to companies and organisations on AI quality and certification.
Clifford Chance
Under the leadership of Thomas Voland, Clifford Chance advises national and international clients on constitutional, state aid and regulatory issues as well as on compliance matters at German and European level. The team has particular expertise in the mobility, infrastructure, healthcare and technology sectors. State aid issues pertaining to the energy transition, such as investments in net zero projects, grid expansion and battery storage, as well as those in the automotive sector represent another mainstay; the latter frequently concerns the construction of battery factories.
Praxisleiter:
Thomas Voland
Kernmandanten
Asterion Industrial Partners
LBS West und LBS Nord
Harbour Energy
German LNG Terminal GmbH
Macquarie Asset Management
Highlight-Mandate
- Advising German LNG Terminal GmbH on the planning, construction and operation of one of the first German liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminals in Brunsbüttel.
- Advising an internationally active OEM on the creation of an information collection system to comply with the requirements of the FSR as well as advising on procurement proceedings in accordance with the FSR.
GSK Stockmann
GSK Stockmann handles various transformation issues related to the energy transition and the turning-point. These include issues relating to the construction of LNG terminals and offshore and onshore wind turbines, as well as electromobility, charging station infrastructure, photovoltaics and digitalisation in the healthcare sector administration. Clients include international industrial companies, hospital groups and investors. The team is jointly led by Arne Gniechwitz, whose expertise is frequently applied to advise German sea and inland port infrastructure companies and who also assists with public partial financing of airports, and Wolfgang Würfel, a proven expert in financing and admissibility of public, mostly municipal projects under EU state aid law.
Praxisleiter:
Arne Gniechwitz; Wolfgang Würfel
Referenzen
‘Excellent advice.’
Kernmandanten
Niedersachsen Ports GmbH & Co. KG
JadeWeserPort Realisierungs GmbH & Co. KG
SBB Suhler Betriebs- und Beteiligungsgesellschaft mbH
Bayerische Staatsforsten AöR, Zentrale
Gemeinde Eichenau
Highlight-Mandate
- Advising Niedersachsen Ports GmbH & Co. KG on the €100 million financing of the construction of an LNG terminal in Stade-Bützfleth.
- Advising Niedersachsen Ports GmbH & Co. KG on the construction of a new pier for liquefied gases in Wilhelmshaven with up to eight ship berths.
- Advising Niedersachsen Ports GmbH & Co. KG on the expansion of the German offshore industry centre in the seaport of Cuxhaven in order to strengthen its key position for German offshore wind energy.
Heuking
Heuking advises public sector clients and private companies, including non-profit associations and organisations, on various procurement, municipal, state aid and corporate issues with a focus on tenders, start-ups and restructuring. The practice is headed by state aid and procurement expert Ute Jasper, who has particular experience in complex projects at federal, state and municipal levels, particularly in connection with awards, restructuring and cooperation.
Praxisleiter:
Ute Jasper
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Christopher Marx; Laurence Westen
Referenzen
‘The staff at the firm always tries to fulfill the client’s wishes and is perceived as very polite. The billing of services is transparent and based on the costs incurred. Overall, the collaboration is extremely pleasant.’
‘Quality competence and the trust that has been built up in the meantime characterise the individuals with whom we have the most frequent contact. The person with whom we have the most frequent contact naturally stands out due to the long-term contact. The commitment to the client stands out in particular. A friendly business relationship has now developed with this person.’
Jones Day
Jones Day's cross-location EU State aid practice is regularly instructed by companies, including those in the energy sector, as well as by ministries and EU member states to assist with complex state aid investigations before the European Commission and in EU and national court proceedings. The team is also well versed in German and European antitrust and competition law. Philipp Werner is considered the key contact for the whole array of state aid issues, including those relating to privatisations, restructurings and insolvencies.
Praxisleiter:
Philipp Werner
Referenzen
‘Top notch. Among the best in class.’
‘Philipp Werner: A truly outstanding shining light.’
‘The team is one of the few in the market that provides intensive advice on state aid law and not just as a side business to antitrust law advice. This goes hand in hand with excellent know-how.’
‘Philipp Werner: Extensive experience in state aid law and very quick comprehension, fast reaction time and a clear view of the essentials. Efficient advice.’
Kernmandanten
RWE AG
Hessisches Ministerium der Finanzen
Highlight-Mandate
- Advice and representation of the Hessian Ministry of Finance on the restructuring of shares in Helaba.
- Advice and representation of RWE AG in state aid proceedings before the EU Commission in connection with the compensation payments proposed by the German Federal Government to energy companies for the political decision to end lignite-fired power generation.
- Advising a German logistics company on a possible state aid complaint regarding cross-subsidisation of a competitor.
Oppenländer Rechtsanwälte
Oppenländer Rechtsanwälte's advice offering is primarily tailored to the transport sector, where its advises clients on the structuring of state aid-compliant compensation payments to transport operators within the framework of sector-specific state aid law. The group is also active in other public service areas, including universities, care facilities and hospitals. Here, the practice advises on the state aid-compliant structuring of general regulations, public service contracts and funding guidelines. This is complemented by expertise in defending clients against state aid complaints brought by the EU Commission and representing them in court proceedings before European courts. Corina Jürschik-Grau heads the group.
Praxisleiter:
Corina Jürschik-Grau
Weitere Kernanwälte:
Christofer Lenz
Referenzen
‘The collaboration with the law firm was goal-oriented and effective. The team’s knowledge of EU funding guidelines and the guidelines in Germany is unique.’
‘Competence, cooperation.’
‘First-class expertise, reliability and friendliness are lived here and not just advertised. A special relationship of trust develops between client and law firm, which gives the client the security of being 100% well represented by the law firm. The involvement of partners in legal areas outside of state aid and public law has clarified issues immediately and helped a lot.’
‘Corina Jürschik-Grau is an outstanding lawyer who has immersed herself 100% in the subject matter of the case down to the smallest detail and has incredible specialist knowledge. Excellent negotiation skills are guaranteed.’
‘Advice tailored to our needs – and our understanding; empathy in dealing with problematic project partners; excellent competence in consulting areas relevant to us; mediation and pragmatic solution-finding even in complex legal problems.’
‘Corina Jürschik-Grau: Very good specialist knowledge, efficient working methods, transparent communication of legal risks.’
‘First-class advice.’
Kernmandanten
Albtal-Verkehrs-Gesellschaft mbH
Hubert Burda Media Holding Kommanditgesellschaft
Donau-Iller-Nahverkehrsverbund-GmbH (DING)
Eisenwerk Erla GmbH
Land Baden-Württemberg, Ministerium für Verkehr (LGVFG)
Landeshauptstadt Stuttgart
SSB AG
Staatliche Toto-Lotto GmbH Baden-Württemberg
Staatsministerium Baden-Württemberg
Stadt Garching
Stadtwerke Baden-Baden
SWM/ MVG
traffiQ Lokale Nahverkehrsgesellschaft Frankfurt am Main mbH
Verkehrs- und Tarifverbund Stuttgart GmbH (VVS)
VVS Verkehrs- und Tarifverbund Stuttgart GmbH (VVS)
Forst BW
Highlight-Mandate
- Advising Donau-Iller-Nahverkehrsverbund-GmbH (DING) on the restructuring of the transport association in accordance with state aid law.
- Advising the State of Baden-Württemberg and the Ministry of Transport on the design of bus funding guidelines in compliance with state aid law.
- Advice to the State of Baden-Württemberg, Ministry of Transport on the design of the public transport funding provisions of the LGVFG.