Hall Of Fame

Clinical negligence: defendant in North West

Clyde & Co

Noted for its ‘unrivalled knowledge and experience of the sector’, the Manchester-based offering at Clyde & Co is well-equipped to defend NHS trusts, med-mal insurers, GPs, and MDOs in the full range of complex and high-value clinical negligence matters wherein often both quantum and causation aspects are contentious. ‘Star individual’ Vanessa Splaine heads up the overall team and leads the NHS Resolution group; Splaine has vast experience handling the remit of complex litigation, with particular experience in high-value brain injuries in new-borns and adults, wrongful birth claims, and serious spinal injury cases. Christina Bateman is experienced in handling severe birth injury cases, spinal injury matters, and multi-party claims; and ‘excellent lawyer’ Andrea Crisp is a name to note with a particular strength in handling claims relating to the Equality Act 2010 and experience acting alongside Splaine in cross-jurisdictional cases. In July 2024, the firm saw the arrival of Chloe Davies, while Sarah Woodwark retired in April 2024.

Praxisleiter:

Vanessa Splaine


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Nicola Perrott; Chloe Davies; Deborah Boyd; Matthew Tippin; Christina Bateman; Andrea Crisp; Jennifer Hovington


Referenzen

‘Clyde & Co have unrivalled knowledge and experience of the sector. They have assembled a strong and determined team with a clear vision of how to achieve the best outcome for their clients without wasting time or costs on irrelevant issues.’

‘Vanessa Splaine is a highly skilled and experienced litigator with outstanding team leadership skills. She combines a strong work ethic with a sunny and friendly personality which feeds down into the rest of the team. She has an instinctive feel for tactics and in getting the best outcome for the client. Matthew Tippin is a very talented senior associate who handles a large caseload of high-value cases without ever compromising on quality.‘

‚Jennifer Hovington is a wise and thoughtful lawyer who gets quickly to the heart of the case. She is not afraid to stand up to a difficult client when necessary.‘

Kernmandanten

Berkshire Hathaway International Insurance Ltd


Medical Protection Society


Dental Protection


RSA


Lewisham and Greenwich NHS Trust


NHS Resolution


MDDUS


Premium Medical Protection


Zurich


Chubb


Hillingdon Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advised a client on an infant brain injury claim; a highly complex claim for NZD60m where settlement was achieved at around NZD13m.

DAC Beachcroft LLP

The Manchester-based team at DAC Beachcroft LLP has noteworthy capabilities in assisting its varied portfolio of clients, which includes key providers of medical services, both public and private, as well as insurers. The team advises clients who are under investigation and defends them at various court levels. The ‘exceptional legal minds’ that form the team include experienced product liability advisor Sean Doherty, who leads the team’s NHS Resolution work and whose areas of specialism range from birth injury claims to orthopaedic-related group actions; Claire Fitzgerald, who boasts expertise in handling mental health-related matters; and Bridie Mahoney, who is experienced in handling high-profile litigation. The team is helmed by London-based Hamza Drabu, Bristol’s Rachel Roberts-Jenkins, and Manchester-based Simon Wortley, who is lauded as an ‘excellent lawyer’ and has experience handling both domestic and cross-jurisdictional matters for the team’s most prominent clients.

Praxisleiter:

Hamza Drabu; Rachel Roberts Jenkins; Simon Wortley


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Sean Doherty; Claire Fitzgerald; Bridie Mahoney; Laura Fu; Jonathan Bonser


Referenzen

‘This practice stands out due to its client-centric approach. It consistently exceeds expectations through innovative solutions and a deep understanding of our specific needs. Potential clients would be impressed by the team’s collaborative spirit and diverse expertise. The team distinguishes itself through its proactive communication, personalised service, and commitment to achieving the best possible results.’

‘The individuals I work with are exceptional legal minds who combine sharp intellect with a practical, results-oriented approach. I have been particularly impressed with Sean Doherty who distinguishes himself through his dedication, responsiveness, and commitment to helping medical professionals learn from medical negligence claims. I am always fully informed and confident in their guidance.’

‘Jonathan Bonser is fantastic at achieving the best results for his clients and is a powerful negotiator.’

Kernmandanten

Circle Health Group


HCA International Ltd


Medical Defence Union


Dental Defence Union


Schoen Clinic UK


Teladoc Health UK


Elysium Healthcare Ltd


NHS Resolution


NHS England


Florence Nightingale Hospital


Insurance Corporation of the Channel Islands


Newline Group


MS Amlin


Allied World Assurance Company


Zurich


Beazley


Royal Sun Alliance


CNA Hardy


Liberty Global


Centre for Reproductive and Genetic Health


One Stop Doctors


21D


Evodental


Marsh McLennan


AMMA Assurance


Medical Professional Liability Co.


Watson Tower Wilson


Intereurope AG


Aon UK


Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust


Greater Manchester Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust


Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Hull University Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust


Barnsley Hospital NHS Foundation Trust


Liverpool University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust


Harrogate & District NHS Foundation Trust


Doncaster & Bassetlaw Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


NOE CPC


NHS SBS


Blackpool Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Luke Cascarini Ltd


Simply Loyal Ltd


Hill Dickinson LLP

Hill Dickinson LLP‘s group spans Liverpool and Manchester and is renowned for its capabilities in representing its wide-ranging roster of clients, which features NHS Resolution, AXIS Insurance, and various NHS Trusts, in a plethora of complex matters. The team is helmed from Liverpool by Andrew Craggs, who acts for some of the team’s most preeminent clients and is particularly experienced in advising on sensitive matters, such as those surrounding sexual assault, stress, and claims of bullying. From the same office, ‘superb operator’ David Locke leads the firm’s national health litigation team and is well-equipped to defend high-profile group action claims and advise on novel issues, such as gender reassignment clinic closures following the Cass Report. Gill Stoll is lauded by clients as a ‘master tactician’; and Joanne Hughes has expertise in GP and dental-related claims. In Manchester, Jonathan Heap acts for private insurer, as well as public sector clients, and frequently works alongside noteworthy practitioner Nick Citron. Jessica Neary departed the Manchester team in January 2025.

Praxisleiter:

Andrew Craggs


Weitere Kernanwälte:

David Locke; Nick Citron; Joanne Hughes; Jonathan Heap; Monia Sood; Nina Sahu; Gill Stoll; Ian Gardiner


Referenzen

‘Gill Stoll is a skilled and experienced litigator with outstanding team leadership skills. She gets quickly to the key issues in a case and is a master tactician, always focused on obtaining a cost-efficient outcome for her client.’

‘Nick Citron is a standout performer. He is efficient and works hard to ensure clients are always satisfied.’

‘Andrew Craggs is an effective leader – astute and energetic in the marketplace. Joanne Hughes handles complex, high-value litigation authoritatively and effectively. Ian Gardiner is a very effective litigator with excellent judgment. Jonathan Heap is a creative and charismatic lawyer who has the courage to develop novel arguments. Nina Sahu is impressive in complex cases.‘

Kernmandanten

NHS Resolution


Shrewsbury and Telford NHS Foundation Trust


Northern Care Alliance


Countess of Chester NHS Foundation Trust


AXIS Insurance


Greater Manchester Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust


Liverpool University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust


Spire Healthcare


Beazley Insurance


CNA Hardy


University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust


Mersey & West Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust


Mersey Care NHS Foundation Trust


Warrington & Halton Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Wirral University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


North West Ambulance NHS Foundation Trust


East Cheshire NHS Trust


Welsh Health Legal Services


Highlight-Mandate


  • Acting for NHS Resolution in relation to litigation claims brought arising out of the neonatal deaths at Countess of Chester Hospital.
  • Acted for a client in the trial win of a clinical negligence claim for NHS Resolution and two NHS Trusts in which the claimant was found to be fundamentally dishonest.
  • Acting on behalf of NHS Resolution and Shrewsbury & Telford Hospitals NHS Trust in relation to the claims brought arising out of the maternity Ockenden review.

Weightmans LLP

The Liverpool-based cohort at Weightmans LLP boast a workload that includes defending its notable list of clients in contentious cases regarding lack of proficient care and catastrophic injury claims, as well as in various group action claims. In addition to its contentious capabilities, the team provides preventative strategic advice on issues including patient safety and risk management. ‘Very experienced litigator’ Ian Critchley heads up the offering alongside Richard Jolly, who is experienced in acting for NHS trusts and private medical clients, and Vicky Morris, who has expertise in patient safety matters and novel cases, as well as in group actions. Medical malpractice and dental negligence cases are specialist areas of Chris Dexter. Birth injury, wrongful birth, and claims involving foetal exposure to sodium valproate are core areas of strength for Lisa Spencer, while June 2024-promoted partner Samuel Harland has significant experience handling product liability and infected blood matters. Jessica Neary joined the team in January 2025.

Praxisleiter:

Richard Jolly; Ian Critchley; Vicky Morris


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Chris Dexter; Lisa Spencer; Alison Brennan; Samuel Harland; Jessica Neary


Referenzen

‘The team provides an excellent service. The team has good experience and expertise of the medical issues underlying claims and prides itself on giving its clients early, sensible and realistic advice.’

‘Ian Critchley is a very able lawyer. He is extremely hardworking and has good judgement. He also has excellent client care skills. He is a very experienced litigator. I have been impressed by his strategic and tactical skills and overall command of his cases. He achieves excellent results for his clients through his clear-sighted identification of the key issues.’

‘Weightmans have real strength in depth. They have a team which is strong at all levels.’

Kernmandanten

NHS Resolution


IDH


Lancashire Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


North West Ambulance Service NHS Trust


Wrightington, Wigan & Leigh NHS Foundation Trust


Tameside & Glossop Integrated Care NHS Foundation Trust


Wirral University Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust


NHS Blood & Transplant


Wirral Community NHS FT


Lancashire and South Cumbria NHS Foundation Trust


Blackpool Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


St Helena Government


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advising NHS Resolution, NHS Blood and Transplant, and various NHS Trusts, amongst others, on several proposed group actions being brought by and on behalf of people infected with viruses, including HIV, hepatitis C, and hepatitis B, through the use of blood and blood products.
  • Advising NHS Trusts on claims involving foetal exposure to sodium valproate.
  • Assisted St Helena Government with the setting up and running of a compensation scheme for any patients who suffered avoidable harm during treatment by a doctor employed in the British Overseas Territory, and there are expected to be over 100 cases.

Browne Jacobson LLP

Often leveraging its national network, Browne Jacobson LLP is active on public inquiries and complex birth injury cases. Having re-joined the team from Clyde & Co in April 2025, practice head Bethan Parry is a key name for healthcare professionals and insurers, leveraging her longstanding experience in surgical error claims and healthcare inquests. Nigel Wood is noted for his expertise in ophthalmic cases, representing a diverse range of medical defence organisations, private healthcare providers, and NHS trusts. Jenny Harrington stands out for her specialism in birth injury claims and early notification scheme issues.

Praxisleiter:

Bethan Parry


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Rachel Mounsey; Nigel Wood; Jenny Harrington