Hall Of Fame

Firms To Watch: Professional negligence

Frank Maher  and Sue Mawdsley lead the Liverpool-based professional negligence practice at Keystone Law, which is adept in professional indemnity insurance coverage disputes.

Professional negligence in North West

Clyde & Co

Described as ‘one of the big beasts in professional negligence’, Clyde & Co continues to advise construction and legal professionals as well as a range of insurer clients. Practice head Louisa Robbins leads the Manchester-based practice and has a wealth of experience handling claims against property and construction professionals, frequently overseeing pre-action and litigated claims. James Preece covers disciplinary claims and investigations against solicitors, barristers and their indemnity insurers, Ben Parks is well versed in policy coverage issues, including misrepresentation claims, while Martin Paxton is praised for his ‘considerable judgement and depth of knowledge’ in solicitor professional negligence claims.

Praxisleiter:

Louisa Robbins


Weitere Kernanwälte:

James Preece; Ben Parks; Martin Paxton; Heather Banner; Becky Stewart; Alexandra Charlton


Referenzen

‘The Clyde & Co professional negligence team have experience and expertise in handling claims of the highest value against a wide range of professionals. They are steeped in the law, and are adept at finding innovative defences and challenges to claims.’

‘Louisa Robbins has an excellent grip on large and complex cases, managing substantial teams and showing an acute sensitivity both to the client’s commercial objectives. James Preece is one of the most distinguished solicitors working in the field of professional liability and professional discipline today. Becky Stewart is impressively rigorous and hard-working, commanding the detail of a case.’

‘James Preece is an exceptionally clever lawyer, whose deep knowledge and understanding of the law enable him to get to the core of the most complex legal issues with ease and precision and to provide comprehensive and informed advice.’

Kernmandanten

Allianz UK


Arch Insurance


AXA XL


Aviva


Bar Mutual Indemnity Fund


Berkshire Hathaway


Ecclesiastical Insurance UK


Financial and Legal Insurance


Hiscox


Pen


QBE


SOMPO International


Travelers Insurance


WRB Underwriting


Zurich Professional and Financial


Highlight-Mandate


  • Acting for Bar Mutual and its insured Dr Sandy Joseph and her clerk David Foreman in a complex claim for £377bn arising from an underlying commercial litigation matter.
  • Acting for a leading global speciality insurer and reinsurer in litigation arising out of the administrations in 2021 and 2023 of two of the UK’s largest claimant law firms. The sum claimed is upwards of £150M plus interest and costs.
  • Acting for Firm of solicitors and its professional indemnity insurers in a claim for in excess of £17M plus interest and costs arising from a failed development and the loss of purchase monies.

DWF

DWF is adept in multi-party claims, primarily representing architects, engineers, solicitors, insurance brokers, managers, accountants and media consultants. The department also advises on various insurance policy mandates. Andrew MacLeod leads the team and is highly regarded for his expertise in the defence of claims made against insurers and their policyholders. Paul Dally has a broad client base and has vast knowledge in Third Party (Rights Against Insurers) Act claims, Mark Jenkyn-Jones assists insurers on policy coverage issues and Hilary Harrison has experience advising insurers on D&O and management liability insurance matters. The team was bolstered in 2024 with the arrival of Caitlin Richardson in March, before John Gibney joined the team from Weightmans LLP in May.

Praxisleiter:

Andrew MacLeod


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Paul Dally; Mark Jenkyn-Jones; Hilary Harrison; Caitlin Richardson; John Gibney


Referenzen

‚Hilary Harrison is an excellent technical lawyer whose experience of working with insurer clients over many years is evident. She is proactive, approachable and a trusted pair of hands in any case.‘

‚I have always found them to take a sensible and pragmatic approach, offering sound and reasoned advice. They are also a Team that makes itself easy to work with and they are adept at building a rapport with their clients. Mark Jenkyn-Jones embodies the attributes set out in my previous answer. Good to work with.‘

Highlight-Mandate


Kennedys

Kennedys defends a broad client roster, comprising professionals across law, construction, insolvency, auditing and insurance, with matters concerning negligence in relation to fire safety and design defects in the construction space, as well as various D&O liability coverage, policy coverage and monitoring matters. Four partners lead the professional liability team, with key names in Manchester including Claire Bushen, who is considered a ‘standout partner’ and advises solicitors and accountants, Tom Handley, who works primarily in the construction space and often defends architects before regulatory bodies, as well as Hannah Williams, who is well versed in policy coverage and D&O liability matters. Lucy Suddaby and Daniel Fairey are further key members of the practice.

Praxisleiter:

Claire Bushen; Tom Handley; Hannah Williams


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Lucy Suddaby; Daniel Fairey; Geoffrey Shreeve; Fran Shaw


Referenzen

‘This is a very strong team. Even junior members instill confidence in clients.’

‘Hannah Williams can do anything taking the most complex matters in her stride. Tom Handley is incredibly reliable.’

‘Very approachable team who have a wide breadth of knowledge in the Defendant professional negligence space. The Manchester team collaborate with their other locations and teams.’

Keoghs LLP

Keoghs LLP houses a ‘first class collaborative team’ that is adept in defending claims bought against construction professionals, solicitors, brokers and insurers, including fire safety, cladding and defects claims in the construction sector, as well as various insurance coverage issues. Ruth Lawrence leads the team and is highly experienced in construction cases, while Christopher Stanton is a go-to name on insurance coverage matters, particularly those relating to solicitors' minimum terms and conditions. Sarah Naylor and Graham Taylor have a niche in advising veterinary professionals against claims, with clients describing the firm’s expertise as ‘second to none’. Jonathan Anslow regularly handles fire safety and cladding disputes against a range of professionals and Rachel Blair handles a variety of claims against solicitors, surveyors and brokers.

Praxisleiter:

Ruth Lawrence


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Christopher Stanton; Sarah Naylor; Graham Taylor; Jonathan Anslow; Rachel Blair; Sarah Elderton; Ellicia Williams


Referenzen

‘Keoghs combine huge experience of professional negligence claims with an in-depth understanding of the construction sector. One of the leading firms for PI insurers, they offer extremely high quality services.’

‘Ruth Lawrence (Partner): a stand-out practitioner in the professional negligence insurance market, Ruth has great disputes resolution and litigation experience in this sector. Rachel Blair is an up-and-coming star in the professional negligence insurance sector. She has great attention to detail and is tenacious and determined – someone you want on your side!’

‘A very professional and friendly team that are quick to identify the issues and the required steps.’

Kernmandanten

RSA


Pen Underwriting


QBE UK Ltd


The Veterinary Defence Society


LawSelect


International General Insurance Co (UK) Ltd


Amtrust at Lloyd’s


CNA Insurance


Arch Insurance


Travelers Insurance Company Ltd


R&Q


Argo Global


Talbot Underwriting


Mills & Reeve LLP

Mills & Reeve LLP defends a wide range of claims, and is recognised for its expertise in handling claims made against legal professionals, which include professional misconduct, unlawful victimisation and wasted costs claims. Further areas of focus include acting for construction professionals in complex disputes, representation of insurance brokers and in directors and officers claims. Ben Hardiman and Niall Innes jointly lead the practice, with Hardiman focusing on construction mandates- frequently relating to the cladding crisis- while Innes primarily handles claims against legal professionals. Emma Harrison and Sarah Rose are active members of the practice and both defend solicitors, barristers and insurance brokers against various cases.

Praxisleiter:

Niall Innes; Ben Hardiman


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Emma Harrison; Sarah Rose; Adrian Kwintner; Daniel Korcz


Weightmans LLP

The professional negligence team at Weightmans LLP is ‘outstanding from senior to junior members’.  The team specialises in high-value, multi-party claims against professionals in the construction sector often concerning fire safety and defects, while also regularly defending cases against legal professionals. Mickaela Fox, who is an expert in indemnity claims, and Mike Grant, who defends various construction and insurance claims, including through arbitration and mediation, jointly lead the practice. Further key members of the team include Alex Marler, who has a broad practice which includes advising on Third Parties (Rights Against Insurers) Act claims, Pamela Freeland who frequently assists major insurers in the sector and Sarah Irwin, who oversees claims in the construction and legal sectors.

Praxisleiter:

Mickaela Fox; Mike Grant


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Alex Marler; Pamela Freeland; Sarah Irwin; Deborah Sullivan


Referenzen

‘A top flight regional insurance practice doing difficult and high value cases nationally and in London. Their insurance law expertise goes far beyond most firms doing equivalent work.’

‘Alex Marler is a standout individual. His level of legal knowledge and enquiring approach go far beyond any solicitor practicing in insurance disputes that I have experienced. He is always coming up with creative ideas.’

‘Mickaela Fox is very client friendly offering advice in straight-forward easy to understand language. Mickaela is ably supported by Deborah Sullivan (Principal Associate).’

Kernmandanten

Tokio Marine HCC


Markel International Insurance Company Ltd, and Markel UK


Wren Insurance Association


WSP


Hamilton Underwriting


AmTrust


Hiscox


Zurich


HDI Global Specialty SE


Bar Mutual Indemnity Fund


Highlight-Mandate


  • Successfully resolved a complex multi-party claim regarding conveyancing searches.

Addleshaw Goddard

Addleshaw Goddard has a strong track record representing claimants in solicitors’ negligence cases across various fields, including construction, business, pensions and financial services. The team also acts in claims made against a range of other professionals including trustees of pension schemes, insurance brokers, surveyors and construction professionals. Victoria Pool and Nick Ashcroft jointly lead the practice, with Pool acting for insurance policyholders in D&O, W&I and risks cover disputes, while Ashcroft excels in business-protection litigation. Pensions dispute expert Susan Garrett retired in June 2024.

Praxisleiter:

Victoria Pool; Nick Ashcroft


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Helen Mattingly; Alex Staniland; Triin Ungert; Clare Dwyer; Paul Rowley


DAC Beachcroft LLP

Acting for major indemnity insurers, solicitors, construction professionals and media clients, DAC Beachcroft LLP has extensive experience defending against a broad range of professional negligence claims, including management liability claims, insolvency related matters, regulatory breaches and contract disputes. Practice head Ian McConkey has a broad practice in which he advises both traditional and emerging professionals and is noted for his ‘expertise in claims arising in a personal injury context’. Lyn Crawford is well versed in CAR and EAR claims, Harald Loeffler focuses on defending PI insurers against various technology and media claims, while Katy Giles specialises in defending claims made against legal professionals. Tom Bedford departed the practice in June 2024.

Praxisleiter:

Ian McConkey


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Lyn Crawford; Harald Loeffler; Katy Giles; James Gardiner


Referenzen

‘Ian McConkey is a very capable and experienced lawyer who proved a safe pair of hands in dealing with a complex matter.’

‘Ian McConkey is the partner whose ability most struck me recently. Ian was first rate combining an excellent grasp of the issues with the people skills necessary to help his clients settle a dispute.’

‘Although it is a small team, they work hard to get close to clients and they work well together to develop relationships with both Insurers and their Insureds. They have worked hard to build their media practice for which they have developed a strong reputation.’

Kernmandanten

QBE European Operations


Travelers Insurance Co Limited


Zurich Insurance plc


Tokio Marine HCC


Great Lakes SE/Munich Re


AmTrust


Liberty Mutual Insurance


HSB Engineering Insurance Limited


Swiss Re


Chubb


Aviva


CNA Hardy


AIG


AXA XL


RSA


Highlight-Mandate


  • Acted for Lexent Partners Limited and its Professional Indemnity Insurers in the defence of a claim brought by the Trustees in Bankruptcy of a former client of the solicitors firm.
  • Acted for the PI Insurers of Medical Architecture and Art Projects Limited in defending a professional negligence claim brought by Laing O’Rourke in the TCC concerning the design of Roseberry Park Hospital in Middlesborough, with particular focus on fire safety issues.
  • Acted for Gorvins Solicitors and their Professional Indemnity Insurers in successfully defending a professional negligence claim brought by an SPV company with stakeholders resident in China, obtaining judgment in favour of Gorvins and an order for payment of their costs.

FS Litigation

FS Litigation stands out due to its strong focus on construction, accounting, tax, pensions and financial services professional negligence matters, where the team acts for claimants. Kit Sorrell and Julia Norris jointly lead the practice and bring extensive experience in high-value commercial litigation and professional negligence matters to the ‘deeply specialised’ team. Nicola Stanley, Christine Newton and John Colvin are further names to note. Joshua Murphy left the team in August 2024, while Sunny Patel departed the outfit in January 2025.

Praxisleiter:

Kit Sorrell; Julia Norris


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Nicola Stanley; Christine Newton; John Colvin


Referenzen

‘FS Legal has been working with me for over ten years and their professionalism, dedication and tenacity has been exemplary. The whole team has always showed compassion for my situation and continued to keep me up to date and informed.’

‘I have a very special shout out for Julia Norris. She has been outstanding in her tenacity to bring a successful outcome in my case. I have also communicated with various members of Julia’s team and always had a high level of professionalism from them, politeness and dedication to their duties.’

‘The team is deeply specialised in professional negligence work arising out of financial services, including miss-selling of investments, failed tax schemes and litigation with the financial regulator (FCA).’

Kernmandanten

Hartley Pensions Limited


Highlight-Mandate


  • Instructed to act for 6 nominated Representative Respondents who represent a wider group of 16,741 pension SIPP holders in a ground-breaking and high-profile matter concerning the collapse of Hartley Pensions Limited (in Administration) and £1.3BN in assets and a £40M claim.

Markel Law LLP

Markel Law LLP is praised for its ability to handle ‘many different, complex, high value and unusual claims’, which often includes defending against product liability claims, recovery actions and policy coverage issues for insurers, while also defending professional negligence claims against solicitors, accountants and insurance brokers. Former practice head Christopher Burns left the practice in September 2024, while Gareth Pickup joined the team from Clyde & Co the following month in November 2024 and leads the practice alongside Mark Rankin. Rankin defends a plethora of claims against various insured professionals, namely solicitors, brokers, accountants and surveyors, while Pickup focuses on construction related property damage and product liability claims.

Praxisleiter:

Mark Rankin; Gareth Pickup


Weitere Kernanwälte:

Aadil Amla


Referenzen

‘Gareth Pickup shows good attention to detail, is good at acquiring a technical knowledge of the subject matter, good at getting to the bottom of the evidence, good at understanding and handling expert evidence & good at assessing the underlying merits of a case.’

‘Gareth Pickup’s knowledge, skills, diligence and care were second to none.’

‘This is a diverse team with a variety of skills and expertise. We have instructed Markel Law on many different complex, high value and unusual claims. They always rise to every challenge and get great results. They have also recruited some excellent solicitors of different levels of qualification who are proving to be very talented, resourceful and bring with them unique experience.’

Kernmandanten

Markel (UK) Limited


Markel Legal Expenses Insurance


Markel International Insurance Company Limited


Federation of Small Businesses


Highlight-Mandate


  • Advised insurers in relation to policy coverage regarding a £2,000,000 claim arising from allegedly defective property refurbishment works.
  • Defending a claim by a property development company in relation to alleged negligence in allowing a planning permission to expire, with the resultant loss of the majority of the development opportunity.
  • Representing a software development company in relation to a claim for breach of contract, negligence and breach of GDPR in relation to issues with a white-labelled Covid-19 testing service.

Myerson Solicitors

Myerson Solicitors has a strong professional negligence offering led by Suzanne Carr, where the team is adept in a range of claims made against surveyors, architects, solicitors, tax advisors and accountants. Additionally, the practice receives a significant number of instructions related to the negligent will drafting, trusts and estate administration. David Jones is a further name to note and is singled out by clients for his understanding of ‘professional negligence and the need to resolve problems’.

Praxisleiter:

Suzanne Carr


Weitere Kernanwälte:

David Jones; Adam Shiffman


Referenzen

‘This is a conscientious and careful team of litigators, very responsive to clients.’

‘Suzanne Carr – careful and conscientious litigator. Adam Shiffman – one to watch for the future – insightful, good lawyer.’

‘Myersons are good resolving the underlying problems as well as prosecuting professional negligence claims. Resolving problems requires knowledge of the law and practice in a variety of areas.’

Kernmandanten

Simplet Limited


Larchwood Investments Limited


TSDES Trading Limited


Knightsbridge Properties (UK) Limited


Highlight-Mandate


  • Representing Larchwood Investments Limited in a professional negligence claim against a law firm following multiple failures to provide proper advice in connection with the assignment of a headlease from Cardiff City Council and the taking of a new lease.
  • Representing Simplet Limited in a claim for professional negligence and/or breach of trust claim against a law firm in circumstances where completion monies were sent to the buyer’s solicitor where the buyer had been subject to a winding up order between exchange and completion.
  • Advising TSDES Trading Limited and Mr and Mrs Birkert in respect of a professional negligence claim against a law firm arising from failures to advise of the requirements of s216 Insolvency Act 1986.